A "modernization" unfortunate ...

A "modernization" unfortunate ...

The Adventures of Tintin, Volume 15: Tintin in the Land of Black Gold (Hardcover)

Customer Review

"Tintin in the Land of Black Gold" knew many avatars before taking the shape it has today. Just before the war began - the atmosphere of the "phony war" is found in the first part of the album - he was forsaken by Hergé to be taken much later and released in 1950. Consequently, Hergé had to modify the script to include it - somehow - the characters appeared in the meantime as Captain Haddock and Professor Calculus.

But the most unfortunate episode is of course the "modernization" Hergé agreed to subject this album under the pressure of his English editor. "Tintin in the Land of Black Gold" would suffer a fate worse than "The black island": in fact, if one may lament the fading of the latter after the orgy of detail and untimely modernization (and anachronistic, given the place of the album Tintin's chronology), the entire geopolitical contextualization that we lose with the new version of "Black Gold". Exit the struggle between Jews and Arabs in Palestine 40 years under British mandate, the references to exit the Irgun, etc. In "Black gold" old version, it is understood that the Khemed is Jordan with oil (the identification is even more evident in "Sea Sharks" because it sees the site of Petra). The new version completely annihilates the link between the work and the news, a specialty of Hergé from "The Blue Lotus" and "The Broken Ear".

Yet it is a great album, especially funny since there Dupondt cross the wall while we Con discovers two of the coolest secondary characters: the Emir Ben Kalish Ezab and his son, "turbulent "Abdallah. A must (as most of Tintin ...), but to read and acquire preferably not in its revised edition.

Highly recommended 1 6 Rank: 5/5
August 23
useless as a dishpan Rank: 1/5
September 4
Remote Release 1 Rank: 5/5
November 21
Receuil news ... Rank: 4/5
March 24
Beautiful pen 1 Rank: 3/5
February 19
Good product BUT ... 39 Rank: 3/5
September 3

Related Reviews


Good size, but unfortunate layout and weak mechanicsLogitech K830 wireless illuminated keyboard with touchpad Living Black (Personal Computers) Maglite modernizationNite Ize LED LUC2-07 Combo Kit Upgrades AA Mini Mag-Lite from Incandescent to LED Technology with on / off switch (japan import) (Sport) Lemony Snicket Makes Unfortunate Events Funny!The Bad Beginning (Series of Unfortunate Events) (Library Binding) A Most Unfortunate Family ...The Bad Beginning. (Rough Cut Edition) (Hardcover) Modernization of Japan - but where are the Western powers?Shogun 2 - Total War: Fall of the Samurai - Limited Edition (computer game) Very unfortunate for Amazon cloudpFolio for Picasa and Google+ Photos (app) Light modernization10x Evolution Pro Line | Sparset! | MR16 LED lamps | AC DC 12V / 5W 30 ° 340 Lumen Warm White Great Giraffe, unfortunately unfortunate PR of pages Vulli and lack of interest in the German health care directivesSophie la Giraffe in a gift box (Baby Product) ... Unfortunate inmatesQeridoo child bike trailer Speedkid2 Blue Q200A (equipment) Good quality, unfortunate function compilation3in1 Alu Stylus for Medion / Yakumo with pens (electronic) To modernize its PCUgreen Converter VGA to HDMI Scaler Portable Audio Supported 1920x1080 for PC, Laptops and projectors, and other, No Need for External Power Supply, Black (Electronics) Contact untrue and unfortunate Canon PromotionCanon PowerShot SX700 HS Digital compact camera 16.1 Mpix LCD Screen 3 "Optical Zoom 30X Black (Camera Photos) The unfortunate Ozawa betrayed by his own publisherArt of Seiji Ozawa, the (CD) "The unfortunate identity" or repented of a philosopher generation 68.The unfortunate Identity (Paperback) Graphically faithful but unfortunate playabilityR-Type (App) It is unfortunate that this practice is quite small.DURAGADGET cleaning wipes for LCD computer monitors, screens, phones and tablets (Personal Computers) very unfortunate that constantly takes off!Sticker Trompe l'oeil view under 30x30cm Porthole Dolphins Marine elected but fits denoch unfortunate dimensionSIMON PIKE Case / Cover Atlanta V anthracite Ventos 9.7 for TREKSTOR SurfTab®, Felt (Electronics) Another unfortunate victim of Loudness WarGreatest Hits (Audio CD)