I've only been 4 years PUR fan, but have all the CDs. Still, I had to pick my best-of CD of course and of course the Fan Edition! I was not disappointed! Sure, some have again what to complain about the lack some songs, but you can now not even please everyone! And yes PUR have let their fans vote, what up to the CD! Anyway, I'm totally satisfied. The live versions bring over concert atmosphere and the newly arranged versions get under your skin. Especially "until the wind turns." For me, the CD runs at least once a day and helps me like 2 years intermission of PUR to survive!