An interesting book but too disjointed style

An interesting book but too disjointed style

ALL Marketers Are Liars (Paperback)

Customer Review

Seth Godin's first book that I read, it left me a little skeptical. The message he is bright and seems relevant to me, but I find the book too long and too disjointed style. The message of the book can be summarized in five points:

1. The competitive advantages become too complex to formulate in one sentence and consumers need to understand what stories are the product and the company.
2. Stories are what make the people believe, irrationally, that certain products are superior to other products. This is what makes people truly believe that a Porsche Cayenne $ 80,000 is higher than a Volkswagen Touareg $ 36 000, while they share almost all their components. We are looking for stories, not products.
3. A smart marketer should aim to produce good stories to increase the effectiveness of its marketing.
4. To be effective, the stories should match the worldview of the target group. If this is not the case, do not try to change the world view of consumers, because the notice of people can not be changed, not change the target group.
5. To distinguish themselves from the competition and the flood of information that arrives daily to the consumer, we must align our history in a way that speaks to consumers.

These points seem very relevant and form a good manual for marketers wanting to build a story for tomorrow a company or products. But it could have been told in fewer pages, by going directly to the point. The first part of the frames is relatively clear and concise, but then I felt the same things were repeated again and again, to the point of drowning most often. Little is said about the ways and means to find the target groups and what are their worldviews. No doubt we should use other marketing knowledge, for my part I do not have.

Moreover, I find the organization of fairly messy book, including the absence of plan or well displayed methods to concretely apply the acquired knowledge into practical actions. You must deduct the method and plan of action from the various distilled clues in the book.

Finally an interesting book, but would have benefited from having fewer pages to be more organized and to propose more concrete transcripts into practical action of distilled knowledge.

Strengths:

* Relevant
* Key ideas to release the book allow to be a manual for practical use

Weak points:

* Disjointed and messy
* Too thick compared to the message delivered
* It must be from the same fishing methods, in steps, to "how-to" for practical use.

Fits and looks good Rank: 5/5
April 29
Only bad Rank: 1/5
May 3
Super! 1246 Rank: 4/5
August 14
A really great series Rank: 5/5
November 16
Save the old radios Rank: 5/5
May 26
nice and clean and convenient Rank: 5/5
February 8

Related Reviews


An interesting story but too poor style!Charly 9 (Paperback) Interesting book but not really a guideGuide bees, bumblebees, wasps and ants in Europe: The identification, behavior, habitat (Paperback) An interesting book but ...The Search: How Google and Its Rivals rewrote the Rules of Business andTransformed Our Cultu re (Paperback) An interesting book but a little longIn the forests of Siberia: February-July 2010 (Paperback) Very interesting book but little shockConversations with God (Paperback) Quality book but too exhaustiveBig Data: A Revolution That Will Transform How We Live, Work, and Think (Hardcover) good book but too short.Nemesis: Sentenced to plead (Paperback) very interesting book, but not for everyoneThe dictionary (Almost) All Whole Numbers (Paperback) Nice book but too much hype about nothingHow To Be Parisian: Wherever You Are (Hardcover) Interesting flavors, but too sweet!Teapot Ländertee enjoyment Set, 1er Pack (1 x 181 g) (Food & Beverage) Interesting but too generalBig Data Strategy (Paperback) Book simple, easy to read and which addresses many interesting points, but there is better!I, gifted (e)? Of early blooming child to adult (Paperback) But very interesting book ...Carved wood patterns (Paperback) Very interesting book to read but criticallyUnderstanding the Empire (Paperback) An interesting book! 4The heiress of Owlon (Paperback) Average book but a potential copyrightThe ideal man: 50 lessons to seduce the woman you like (Paperback) An interesting start but the rest is slowingThe Highlander, T1: The captive Highlander (Paperback) A good thought but somewhat disjointed scriptResident Evil: Revelations (Video Game) I can understand what so many find great about the book, but unfortunately for me it was just mediocre.The Darkest Minds (Hardcover)