Comparison Test: Philips SCD 610 vs.  603 vs.  NUK vs.  Audio Line V120 2

Comparison Test: Philips SCD 610 vs. 603 vs. NUK vs. Audio Line V120 2

Audio Line 900984 digital cordless video baby monitor V 120 (Baby Product)

Customer Review

Hi, I shall be brief: Have the following four devices in direct comparison test it because I have made tame and completely unsettled the entire reviews. Here is my conclusion:

Basically, first, some facts on all devices:

- The operation of the devices is in the end just at all. Depending on the scope of functions something more complicated, but complicated to use, none of the devices. All without manual intuitively.
- The range was the same in my test at all. In an old building on the 3rd floor I could come safely to the ground floor, in the basement only occasional aborts the connection. When I leave the house, all units have made the opponent (except NUK, which had some reception at the door).
- The ECO-mode (device activates itself with noises) works on all devices, and also in all perfectly.
- A visual LED display when the baby cries all, except for the NUK. And therefore for us also not acceptable.
- The battery life is acceptable at all
- A temperature display have Philips devices not unfortunately. Very sad, otherwise they would be perfect in my opinion.
- The many comments of the problem with wireless I can not determine. Here are approximately 8 WLAN networks active without critical impact on the connection. What causes problems is when more than one baby monitors are active simultaneously, eg from direct neighbors!

Philips AVENT SCD 610:

+ Adjustable sensitivity
+ Zoom function (though the benefit is small)
+ Top Design
- No temperature display

Philips AVENT SCD 603:

+ Nightlight (quite nice)
+ Battery operation of the camera possible
+ Reasonable price
+ Nachlieder the baby part playable (with perfect volume and good quality)
+ Top Design
- Sensitivity of sound activation can not be set (but is not necessary because very sensitively adjusted and similar to the 610 in the most sensitive mode)
- No temperature display
- No zoom (but you need not necessarily)

NUK ECO Control + Video:

+ Temperature display
+ Optimum video image
+ Minimal better range
+ Intercom function (with terrible quality)
+ Good ZOOM
- Has no LED indicator the noise! That to me is killer criterion, because I thus get no optical signal in the shower or in silent baby monitor!
- High price
- Songs have cruel quality!

Audio Line V120:

+ Temperature display
+ Favorable price of all
+ Intercom function (with terrible quality)
+ Vibrate
+ Zoom function (though the benefit is small)
- Cheap housing
- No stand-function in the parent for the fitting
- Camera extremely limp, does not always stable

For me won 603 at the end of the cheap Philips. It provides the basic functions for us. Unfortunately, there is a temperature gauge, but it responds reliably, night songs can play and has a nice design (especially the camera) and for us as a camper a great feature: The camera can be operated if necessary with batteries, perfect for the holiday with Camping mobile or tent ! Or even during power failures ...

Recommended 317 Rank: 4/5
October 21
Small battery with UV lamp Rank: 5/5
May 18
do not buy above 2 Rank: 1/5
January 25
SUPER 1880 3012 Rank: 5/5
May 25
Perfect 1 9547 Rank: 5/5
December 14
Suspense guaranteed 3 1 Rank: 4/5
February 13

Related Reviews


Comparison Test: Philips SCD 610 vs. 603 vs. NUK vs. Audio Line V120Philips Avent SCD610 / 00 baby monitor Video monitor with at least 150m range (Baby Product) Comparison Test: Philips SCD 610 vs. 603 vs. NUK vs. Audio Line V120 1NUK 10256296 - Baby Phone Eco Control + Video, Full Eco Mode 100% free of high-frequency radiation in standby, night vision function, temperature sensor, lullabies (Baby Product) Comparison Test: Philips SCD 610 vs. 603 vs. NUK vs. Audio Line V120 3Philips Avent SCD603 / 00 Digital Baby Monitor with video function (Baby Product) Philips SCD 525 is much too quiet!Philips Avent SCD525 / 00 ECO DECT Baby Monitor (Baby Product) Arcam IRDAC - comparison test and reasons for the "For"Arcam IRDAC DA Converter (Electronics) PRODUCT TEST PHILIPS RQ1187 / 45 Senso Touch 2D wet and dry shaver incl. Bart Tyler and nose u. Ear hair trimmerPhilips RQ1187 / 45 Senso Touch 2D wet & dry shaver (Bart Tyler and nose u. Ear hair trimmer) (Health and Beauty) Comparison between Philips and KrupsPhilips HR2095 / 90 Avance Collection Blenders (6 ProBlend technology, 700 W) Black (Kitchen) Superboard (comparison test)Ridge Skateboard Mini Cruiser Complete Board Fully assembled (equipment) My personal comparison test: eSmart loses significantlyeSmart Germany Optima Warm White LED Spot | 5W (35W) | GU10 | Diameter: 48mm | Length: 70mm Blu-ray test Philips BDP 5700/12Philips BDP5700 / 12 Blu-ray Disc player with 3D playback (Miracast, Smart TV, USB) (Electronics) ... After winning the Beem-internal comparison testBEEM Germany Nobilis kettle, 1.7 liter, Copper-Style (household goods) Comparison TestKoss Sporta Pro Headphones (Electronics) The memory card comparison testLexar Professional Thin Box 32GB CompactFlash memory card 1000x (Electronics) Well - could be better (Review & Comparison for Philips Sonicare Diamond Clean)Braun Oral-B electric TriZone 6000 premium toothbrush (with Bluetooth) (Health and Beauty) Comparison Test: Lenovo Z710 I7: 4700MQ 740M vs. 4702MQ 745mLenovo IdeaPad Z710 43.9 cm (17.3-inch FHD LED glare) Notebook (Intel Core i7 4702MQ, 3.2GHz, 16GB RAM, 1TB 5400RPM HYBRID SSHD (8G), NVIDIA GeForce GT 745m / 2GB, DOS) black ( Personal Computers) Comparison Test: price / performance ratioSony MDR-E 818 LP Headphones (Electronics) Baby listening Philips scd / 580/00Philips Avent Listen Baby - Dect SCD580 Rechargeable / 00 (Baby Care) and now the comparison testSpirit E-210 Original, BBQ