Does not smell like aftershave

Have chewed today the shower gel and eau de toilette. The smell similar to each other, but not even come close to the aftershave.
Have both bought in Müller in Vienna. Whether you like the smell, everyone has to find out for yourself, but it is not true that the two products as the aftershave smell - not even close.

Smell a little bitter, perhaps even as tobacco, but not nearly as male and dull, like the aftershave smells. But that is probably because that these products have different compositions, logically!

Man should therefore smell the sample gel and eau de toilette before top one she likes. But who thinks he bekämt the same scent as the aftershave, will be disappointed. The less I understand the reviews here that say otherwise. Or the smell of Tabac has changed in recent years?