Good massage mat but only one speed

Before buying decision I've tried four different massage cushions, since neither the many customers recessions
nor the manufacturer homepages provide a satisfying and above all comparable range of information. For the
Comparison I had two versions with a neck massage unit (88930 Medisana MCN and Beurer 649.40 MG 250) and two without
this trim level (HoMedics CBS-1000-EU and Beurer 646.07 MG 220) selected. All seat covers were in a
Office chair tested in an upright sitting position. To ensure comparability, I have measurable criteria
gathered that I had found anywhere. As reference measuring points I have felt the pressure points on my
Remeasured back in relation to the seat pad or select the external dimensions of the products in the maximum principle.

The following table should enable a comparison, so I have listed in all the same ratings comparable table.

Type cushion | Beurer 646.07 MG 220 | HoMedics CBS-1000-EU | 88930 Medisana MCN | Beurer 649.40 MG 250

Massage areas:

Distance from the | 8 cm | 13 cm | 14 cm | 10 cm
Seat bottom

Distance from the | 60 cm | 68 cm | 55 cm | 45 cm
Seat top

Massage width (max) | 18 cm | 28 cm | 18 cm | 18 cm

Lower back | 0-30 cm | 0-34 cm | 0-30 cm | 0-30 cm

Upper back | 30-60 cm | 34-68 cm | 30-55 cm | 30-45 cm

Length of | 217 cm | 272 in | 177 | 300 cm
Power cable

Seat width | 41cm | 43cm | 39cm | 41cm

Seat length | 38 cm | 38 cm | 37 cm | 38 cm

Back width | 43 cm | 47 cm | 43 cm | 43 cm

Body length | 70 cm | 82 cm | 70 cm | 80 cm

Ergonomics | +++ | ++ | + | +++
Remote

Features: | Beurer 646.07 MG 220 | HoMedics CBS-1000-EU | 88930 Medisana MCN | Beurer 649.40 MG 250

Back completely | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes

Upper back | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes

Lower back | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes

Role Massage | Yes | Yes | No | Yes

Shiatsu Massage | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes

Heating | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes

Spot Massage | Yes | Yes | No | Yes

Number of | 2 | 1 | 1 | 2
Speeds

Shoulder Massage | No | Yes | Yes | Yes -

Vibration in the seat | no | yes | yes | no

Width adjustment | no | yes | no | no
the massage heads

Height limit | no | yes | no | no
the Massage Zone

Neck massage | no | no | 56 cm | 56-66 cm

Cover removable | yes | yes | no | no

Processing | +++ | +++ | + | ++

Ergonomics | - | + | - | -
Remote control pocket

| Beurer 646.07 MG 220 | HoMedics CBS-1000-EU | 88930 Medisana MCN | Beurer 649.40 MG 250

Weight | 4,1 kg | 6.7 kg | 5.4 kg | 6.1 kg

Transport ergonomics | ++ | only with pocket well | - | ++

Seat comfort | +++ | + | - | +++

Massage feeling | +++ | +++ | - | -

Conclusion:

None of the seat cushions can be used as a permanent seat cover such. As in a car, as the massage heads are always noticeably felt.
The two seat pads with neck massage function fell through in my review because the shiatsu unit below the shoulder blades
stops massaging and not bring the neck massage units the desired relaxation effect.

Between the Beurer 646.07 MG 220 and the HoMedics CBS-1000-EU I was indifferent. The Beurer has in my opinion the better massage heads
and two selectable speeds. The HoMedics against a wider and higher massage area, so that a shoulder massage effect
was achieved. When Homedics me have the protruding "Love trading-squeezing" disturbed at the seat and that the seat without the
Can transport carrying case poorly. On the vibration function in the seat can be dispensed with.
Had the Beurer been an approximately 10 cm higher massage area, which would probably have become my choice.
My wife was of the HoMedics more done, so we decided in the end for this variant.