Good PC case - Super Silent housing still far away ...

Good PC case - Super Silent housing still far away ...

Fractal Design OEM PCGH-CA-DEF-R4 ATX Midi Define R4 PC case (accessory)

Customer Review

...
... At least in the state of delivery.

The move my PC from a 15 year old computer case - Big Tower 190x660x420 (WxHxD) - in this Fractal Design Define R4 PCGH Edition computer case - Tower 235x465x525 (WxHxD) - went unspectacular.
However, I must confess that I was both positive and negative surprises out of the box and open the housing. On the one hand there is the continuing even up to a perfect and absolutely vibration-free Super Silent housing a simple functional design with elaborate design elements and on the other hand, the lack of consistency.

Here is my review on the installation of all components and 2 weeks Terms:

Positives:
+ Simple timeless design designed in Sweden and manufactured in China!
+ Solid screw, thumb screws for housing sidewalls and ODD drives
+ 4 chassis fan 140/120 mm possible, including 2x front (1x incl.), 1x base, 1x rear (1x incl.)
+ Behind the front door 2 external 5.25 shafts and fan control (5V / 7V / 12V) for 3 fans
+ Two internal cages with 3 or 5 drawers for 8 drives (HDD 3.5 / 2.5 HDD / SSD 2.5)
+ The central cage with 5 drawers can be removed to mount even long graphics cards (up to 400 mm)
+ The 3.5 HDD's are mounted on the drawers by means of special rubber bushings + special screws
+ The 2.5 HDD's are mounted with rubber wheels + screws
+ Between Motherboard and side wall there is the possibility to install 2 additional 2.5 SSD
+ All necessary screws and mounting parts are available

Negatives:
- There is only one LED for power indication, either POWER ON or ON HDD
- The brightness of cool white (not blue, like on some product pictures) LED is extremely bright and displayed enormous
- I have front-facing part of the LED lighting area need to mask off with black tape, so it's bearable. Now the ring only lights around the power button.
- Why it does not work with subtly illuminated LED in orange or blue, like on my monitor or my external HDD's?
- From the case only the 2 sides and the top are covered with 3 mm thick anti-drone matting, the rest is blank
- The front door, made of high gloss black Plasikmaterial is internally covered with a 3 mm anti-drone mat plus a 5 mm thick foam board
- I can "hear HDD's (in the old housing they hung in 5.25" The vibrational noise of 2 old 3.5 manholes in rubber buffers, no metallic connection and no sound)
- Connection of the 3.5 "HDD's using the special rubber bushings and screws can not prevent the spread of the vibration noise of the old HDD's
- A totally free-swinging mounting the HDD's (suspension in rubber buffers) is not possible.
- The drive cages are firmly screwed to the housing (by a minor design change this could be mounted on rubber pads)
- The firm screw the vibrations to the entire computer case be transferred
- Are even more to hear the vibrations in computer case closed than in open condition
- As a front case fan can be mounted two fans in size 140 mm with double-frame construction (eg Fractal, NOCTUA, Pabst), because they are attached with clips
- For example, "Silent Wings" and "Shadow Wings" fans of "be quiet!" only a middle frame. To Screw holes must be drilled!
- Only for 120mm fans are screw holes exist

Reconstruction of housing and installation of the components:
To improve the sound I have pasted all metal surfaces inside the enclosure, including the bonded with anti-drone matting surfaces, with 10 mm acoustic foam. This acoustic foam has a high tensile strength and elastic 30 micron thick polyurethane coating that is easy to clean and still has a large airborne and Körperschallabsorbtion. The acoustic foam normally used in the computer industry are usually coated with a layer of fabric or a perforated leatherette layer

The 2-mounted fan "Fractal Silent Series R2" (140 mm) I have replaced with 2 fans "be quiet Silent Wings 2" (140 mm) - 1x front and 1x rear.
I was taken aback, which are major difference there between these two types of fans.
The be quiet! Fans run even at 12 V (max. Speed) quieter than the fractal fan at 5 V. The two fractal fan produce at 12V (max. Speed) unbearable vibration noise.
As CPU Cooler I have the ARCTIC Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2 (fan 120 mm, weight 600 g) installed. Despite its enormous dimensions of 130x100x130 (LxWxH) is still a lot of space around (in height, up to the side wall, there are still 50 mm) and 4 RAM spaces are freely accessible.

After assembly, I had my Supersilent computer only a faint noise of 120 mm power supply fan can be heard

Summary of all components that have contributed to my Supersilent computer:
+ Computer case described here "Fractal Design Define R4 PCGH Edition"
+ Acoustic foam - acoustic foam with foil selfadhesive !!! 100x200x1cm Noncombustible P063 - necessary is only 1 m²
+ 2 chassis fan - Silent Wings 2, 140mm be quiet!
+ Power Supply - "be quiet EQT E8-400W!" - This power supply is currently not available for purchase Amazon
+ HDD (old) - 1x Seagate 500 GB, 5 years in operation and 1x Samsung 320 GB, 2 years in operation
+ HDD NEW 2 piece - Seagate SV35 Series ST1000VX000 Internal HDD 1TB (8.9 cm (3.5 inch), 7200 rpm, 8 ms access time, 64MB cache, SATA-600)
+ Motherboard Gigabyte - Gigabyte GA-78LMT-USB3 motherboard Socket AM3 + (ATX, AMD Phenom / Athlon, 4x DDR3 memory, 6x SATA II, 4x USB 3.0)
+ RAM - Corsair XMS3 8GB (2x4GB) DDR3 1333 MHz (PC3 10666) Desktop Memory (CMX8GX3M2A1333C9)
+ CPU Cooler - ARCTIC Freezer Xtreme Rev. 2 - processor cooler for power users - Compatible with Intel and achieves 160 Watts cooling capacity by 120 mm PWM fan - also for AMD3 +
+ CPU - AMD Athlon II X4 640 Quad Core processor (3GHz, Socket AM3, 2MB cache, 95W) - currently unavailable
+ Operating System: Windows 7 Professional 64-bit

Conclusion:
The Fractal Design Define R4 PCGH Edition computer case is a good case with a large room for improvement. Who makes himself the trouble and the housing,
like me, with acoustic foam lining (it is sufficient 1 m² acoustic foam with foil selfadhesive !!! 50x50x1cm 4 pieces Non-combustible P154) and the supplied
Case fan against the 140 mm fan "Silent Wings 2" from be quiet! replaced, and a silent CPU Cooler (the original fan is extremely loud) used, which gets a really
silent computer case.

For the case with the good expansion possibilities there are of me 4 stars, despite the small weaknesses.

Addendum 11.17.2013:
The vibration noise of old hard drives - 1x Seagate 500GB, 5 years in operation and 1x Samsung 320 GB, 2 years in operation - are by the acoustic foam
become quieter, but not gone, because acoustic foam absorbs mainly the airborne sound and not the structure-borne noise.
Because of Schwingungsgeräuse I have the old hard drives now expanded.
The 2 new hard drives - Seagate SV35 Series ST1000VX000 Internal HDD 1TB (8.9 cm (3.5 inch), 7200 rpm, 8 ms access time, 64MB cache, SATA-600) -
are not heard, absolutely silent and cold (max. 34 ° C operating temperature, because right behind the front fan).
And the ARCTIC Freezer XTREME cools the CPU to 35-45 ° C operating temperature, depending on the load.

[...]

Super value for money 21 Rank: 5/5
April 9
Great help to prepare Rank: 5/5
May 21
Largest shit !! Rank: 1/5
January 31
Music of the moment ... 1 Rank: 3/5
December 25
Dear SIGEL company Rank: 2/5
September 21
but although 437 Rank: 5/5
February 5

Related Reviews


Super Silent HousingFractal Design OEM PCGH-CA-DEF-R4 ATX Midi Define R4 PC case (accessory) Fast, but still far away from SATA IIIDelock 2.5 External enclosure SATA HDD 42492> Multiport USB 3.0 + eSATAp (up to 15 mm HDD) (Accessories) Super very good quality caseIVSO®-Book Case Slim Leather Case with Stand for ASUS Memo Pad 10.1-Inch Smart ME301T Tablet (Blue) (Personal Computers) Really good but still far behind GothicRisen 3: Titan Lords - Collector's Edition (computer game) the only good, noble case for the music in 2014!Masstige Cambridge Diary Klapptasche with Smart On / Off function for Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 in 2014 khaki (Accessories) Good quality case. 10Luxury Case Cover for Samsung Galaxy S4 IV + PEN and 3 FILMS AVAILABLE !! (Electronic appliances) Very good quality at super low price2 x 500 Zelletten, cellulose swab in foil Pack (Health and Beauty) Good Life caseDEUFA-FAL. 5001 wire box trap 15 x 5 x 5 cm, 1 entrance (garden products) Good leather case for nikon1TARION Case / Cover / Cover / Case / Photo apparatus PU Leather Bag for Nikon 1 J2 11-27,5mm Camera + Lens / Lens 10mm / 18.5mm Lens (Black) (Accessory) Good classy case!CaseBase - Folio Case Cover for LG OR G3 S / Beat LG G3 / G3 LG Mini with support internal storage and viewing. (Wireless Phone Accessory) Case super! 1Seluxion - Cover Shell Case Pouch Wiko Cink Peax with HF01 pattern (Electronics) Goods as described, super servicePrinter-Express Super XXL Toner replaced Brother TN-2220 TN2220 5400 pages (Office supplies & stationery) Super PC housingMS-Tech CA-0300 Raptor NG PC case (Midi Tower, ATX, USB 3.0) (Personal Computers) All The Best! Again and again! Part OK for the price! Goods work after a few weeks still! Children are pleased!Skylanders Swap Force - Battle Pack (Bumble Blast, Terrafin, Caultron) (Accessories) Goods came after a short time with me, everything went quickly and the quality was good so all super!Narrow tie 5cm black hand-stitched (Textiles) Far away from plug and playTranscend USB 3.0 interface card / adapter PCIe (2 ports) (Personal Computers) It comes from far away.HP 351XL Ink Cartridge Matching (Office Supplies) Far away from guitar musicMylo Xyloto (Audio CD) Far away from the originalKitchen Craft crank grater, stainless steel (houseware)