I have gained this bag for the Motorola Milestone as the 'recommended' bag in my opinion is very impractical (and the phone does not fit). Also this bag can not completely protect Milestone - about 1cm is still out - but for me, this protection is sufficient (and you can still see the Mail LED, which can be interpreted as a bonus).
The tab for pulling is simply practical and fulfills its purpose properly. The processing of the bag is high quality and the price is very good.