More audible than expected, but very enjoyable!

More audible than expected, but very enjoyable!

Scythe Mugen 4 PCGH Edition, suitable for all base (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

I decided after intensive research for the Scythe Mugen 4 PCGH (PC Games Hardware) Edition because it lt. Test reports is top notch in noise abatement and yet can keep up with the cooling capacity with the upper-class fans. That he however really completely permanently running on 800RPM, and uses no PWM control, I have until after you order - and before delivery - noticed. Nevertheless, it is the cooler of my choice.

Also in the final round came the Thermalright Macho HR02, which probably is quite equivalent to a total of - but is offered to me with too many different fan combinations. What is the combo of the review, I then asked myself. In addition, the Noctua NH-D14, the rausflog but because of the price. Alpenföhns chunks to seemed loud and I was too often on Stammtisch level recommended - ie from people who only read parroting. The beQuiet Blackrocks I also due to the higher price levels to 70, - Euro and not elected because of multiple bad experiences with beQuiet power supplies.

The Scythe Mugen 4 PCGH so was my choice.
It comes with a little skimpy instructions, therefore it should be mentioned: It keeps parts left as supplied with 755, 6.5.1050, 2011 each different material for AMD and Intel as well as the base. In my case I have the 1050s parts needed.
Installation is not difficult, you do not need 2 pairs of hands, how many write here. However, there is definitely a bold malice *** during installation, and a construction weakness *** 2 (in my opinion).

Once the boxed cooler that accompanied with my i7-4790K, could keep these at full capacity not even in the normal cycle of 4GHz below 100 ° C (!!!) urgent action was required. In general I have no overclocking ambitions.
I, however, the Z97X-UD3H GIGABYTE GA-BK-have, I have it at least once tested as the Scythe was it.

4GHz clock:
The CPU is almost always kept even under full load at 60 ° C! (55-57 ° C in most cases). For this I have used Photoshop CC and an oil filter (noise> Greystoration, only as a plugin available) run over a 24MP picture ... it takes a while.

OC 4,7GHz clock:
Gigabyte GA-Z97X-UD3H-BK provides a car-OC to function independently, the maximum values ​​determined yet are stable with which the board and the CPU. These things I have tried and lt. PassMark Software extracted good 15% increase effective.
Using the same test, the temperatures of all the cores were usually around 80 ° C. However, there were also occasionally peaks that went over 90 ° C.

As I said I have no OC ambitions, and me 15% increase in performance also no risks are worth, my PC is back on track with the 4GHz. The K version I've ever even brought me, because she is 400-500MHz faster than the non-K version. I could overclock, is a nice benefit, but not important to me.

#### CONCLUSION ####
Overall, I am so absolutely happy with the cooler. Although I would have imagined it a little quieter, but he makes up for that by its noise is completely unobtrusive and not annoying. So I can live with that.
For 40-50, - Euro I feel cooler than a perfect choice. Although the Noctua should have a superior fixing and performance, as well as cost twice as much.

I have, incidentally, still a short video, which demonstrates the noise of the fan. Please note that I have not activated briefly using cable ties brake :-) the power supply fan at the beginning of the video. When I pull the cable tie, it is a bit noisy (if you can call it at all so). In any case the power supply is still louder than the Scythe Mugen 4 PCGH. And I wanted to show it.
-> [...]

LG Mario!

*** The fat trick:
What you never see on the product photos: The complete coolness is screwed by means of a "plank" with the board. It is therefore not about - as I thought - at the four ends of the cross bracket which is mounted on the rear side of the motherboard attached directly.
But a plank is carried out between the slats and the heatspreader, and then with 2 screws (!) - Ie one per page - the horizontal plank is screwed (the radiator piggyback) on the motherboard.
The problem is that you can not screw in both screws simultaneously nunmal. So there is a risk, the radiator does not plan, but to fasten the left and right lower higher. Or. left and right solid loose, which affects the heat dissipation. Here I recommend always patiently to make only half a turn per bolt, so as not to lose balance.

*** 2 The construction Weakness
This is derived from the above-described facts. The condenser is therefore only held horizontally centered. Due to its weight so he pressed himself down more, and lose on top of the CPU for downforce. Personally, I have found that my CPU cores drive 0,2,3 very same temparatures, Core 1, however, always (!) 3-5 ° C more identifies. Mglw. a consequence.

EDIT !!: The "design weakness" appears to be probably widespread. Anyway, this is the predominant type, as well as all other manufacturers fortify their cooler. I find not good, but then probably at least not a disadvantage of this cooler alone!

Rotten Sound quality Rank: 2/5
January 25
A must 16 1 Rank: 5/5
December 17
your very good Rank: 5/5
October 25
Too unreliable to mountain biking Rank: 2/5
October 30
no use 17 Rank: 1/5
March 11

Related Reviews


Quite differently than expected, but very goodThe Casual Vacancy (Hardcover) More space than expected, but it frays outHotter Case II Netbook Bag Nylon black from 22.6 to 25.9 cm (8.9 to 10.2 inches) for example Netbook Medion Akoya, Samsung Nc 10, Acer Aspire One D150 or, ASUS EEE, LG, MSI Wind and much more. (Electronics) Smaller than expected, but very sharp.Xclou Garden Florist scissors m. Finger protection display, Multi-colored, 17x2x5 cm (garden products) More expensive than others but perfect!ActionWrap - Sports armband case specifically for Samsung Galaxy S3 & S2 (Electronics) Better and more robust than expected.Brilliant Desklamp Paddy Sw G64548 / 06 (household goods) More space than expectedMySleeveDesign backpack with extra laptop compartment for notebook and laptop size 13.3 / 14 / 15.6 inches - MISC. DESIGNS (Personal Computers) Smaller than expected but perfectly formedTrust Micro Optical Netbook Mouse Scroll pink (Accessories) More plastic than expectedOlympus 10 x 50 DPS I Binoculars with Case (Electronics) Significantly more solid than expectedCitizen Women's Watch XS Promaster Sea Eco-Drive Diver Stainless Steel Analog EP6040-53E (clock) Installation was a little more complicated than expected, since the Quick Start Guide is incomplete and access switch silent.AVANTEK USB 3.0 External Hard Drive Enclosure for 2.5 inch SATA I II III HDD SSD Up to 4TB [Tool-free assembly] (Electronics) More guitar than expectedEat Me, Drink Me (Audio CD) better than expected, but still with problems!Battlefield: Bad Company 2 (Uncut) - Limited Edition (Video Game) more economical than indicated, but: .....Gorenje RBI4122AW built-in refrigerator / A ++ / 173 kWh / year / refrigerator compartment: 182 L / freezer: 17 L / white / defrost fully automatic in the refrigerator / Interior Lighting (Misc.) Top home improvement - more stable than expectedCON: P pliers set 4-piece, B25665 (tool) Colors more intense than expectedFallen Mens T-Shirt Trademark (Sports Apparel) Tougher than expected, but okSmart Protectors! Soft Case / Cover for iPhone 5 / 5S / 5 S BLACK (Electronics) Smaller than expected, but good valueHits (TM) 5 CLAMP PLATE CUTTING TOOL Unit ROUND DESIGN JEWELLERY LEISURE SCRAP PEARL (Miscellaneous) slightly harder than expected but fulfills the functionmumbi TPU Silicone Case for iPod Nano 7G sleeve (7th Generation) white transparent (Wireless Phone Accessory) Beautiful role, is smaller than expected, but like recordedSigikid 40609 - active role PlayQ (Toys)