Operation capricious and too limited compatibility

Operation capricious and too limited compatibility

Samsung HDMI Adapter for Samsung Galaxy S3 - Black (Accessory)

Customer Review

I admit I was pretty disappointed with this adapter, leaded by compatibility restrictions and use, and did not meet my needs.

In principle, this is already quite "heavy" since the adapter needs to run an HDMI cable to connect the TV and a USB cable for power supply.
Also note that the phone does not go to sleep while it is connected to the adapter, and continues to discharge even though the adapter is connected to a USB power.

Given all that intrigue, one comes to wonder why manufacturers do not stay in the classical microHDMI port that had the merit of simplicity and efficiency.

For in fact, the adapter shows capricious ... including the Samsung Galaxy S3 .... even though it was designed for that specific phone.
The display on the TV does not always run as expected, and then you find yourself in front of a black screen. In this case, there is no choice but to reconnect the devices in a different order from that recommended by the manual. And then, miracle! This works again .. Why? This I know, and it's a mystery ... annoying.

On the other hand, if you were hoping to use the adapter with a Galaxy S4, it is better to shower your hopes up (it's for your own good).
I tested the connection with two televisions. For one, it works (under the same conditions with an S3, ie that sometimes see the devices connection order).
For another, it's the full black screen. And to do anything to resolve the issue. Digging through the settings of the TV or the telephone, nothing works. Black Screen!

So we can say, yes, the device is labeled "consistent Galaxy S3".
Admittedly, this is what I see, but I guess I'm not the only home of France and Navarre to have a S3 and S4 of.
So I question the relevance of proposing X X HDMI Adapters phones generations of the same brand.
Redo buy a new HDMI adapter every time you change phone? That may well be the purpose of the maneuver after all ...

In all cases, both pecuniary and practical level, I think that the micro-HDMI port was more interesting and that these new adapters (called MHL) decidedly more problematic than anything else.

I think the manufacturers would have been better to look to this annoying restriction "HDCP" beating down the whole point of an HDMI connection with Android phones (like the Samsung Galaxy). HDCP has this frustrating it prevents any such capture with a video acquisition device. And Android, HDCP is constantly activated, which means that it is not possible to capture a movie (that's normal) but it is not possible to capture a play session or a beast any manipulation (and it is already less logic).

The only thing one can do with the HDMI (and this adapter) is deport the display of the phone (Galaxy S3) on a TV.
To watch a video, to display a game on the big screen. Knowing that the result is not necessarily a brilliant manipulation and tedious hair.

In the end, I'm not at all convinced.

Very good sound, very good fit Rank: 5/5
April 29
Blah blah ... 89 Rank: 1/5
October 14
good article 179 Rank: 3/5
December 6
Makeup Palette 1 1 Rank: 4/5
April 25
solid 135 Rank: 3/5
June 28

Related Reviews


Very big potential but ultimately too limited in multimediaLenovo Yoga Tablet Tab 2-1050 tactile10.1 "Grey (Intel Atom, Hard Drive 16GB, Android 4.4 KitKat) (Personal Computers) The beautiful object too limited performanceMoshi 99MO018202 Hub FireWire / USB combo (Personal Computers) Too limited content for the priceDisney Infinity 2.0: Marvel Super Heroes - Starter Pack (Video Game) Good but limited compatibilityRemanufactured Ink Cartridge for Lexmark: 28 (18C1428E) Black (Office Supplies) Much too small and too lightEichhorn 100004540 - throwing game (toy) poor workmanship and too smallPhoto Bag Camera Case BLACK ACTION Set with Table Tripod (Electronics) Unfortunately, not my taste and too heavy materialACEVOG ladies dress party dress lace Slim Dress Ärmlos (Textiles) hull and too thin at the end of one week the four corner that serves to maintain the already broken his phone so trashExtra Slim Case Cover Purple for Sony Xperia Z2 and 3 + PEN FILM OFFERED! (Electronic devices) Book null and too politically correctDO THE FRANCE (Album) Beautiful, soft to the touch and too cute!Emtec ECMMD8GL101 Memory Stick 8GB USB 2.0 Looney Tunes Sylvester Reason (Accessory) impractical, too small and too magnifyingLittle magnifying mirror 20x "EXTREME" (Others) too small and too short plug40W AC Adapter Charger AC Adapter for Laptop HP Compaq Mini 210. With European standard power cable. E-port24® disappointed because the provider does not specify that the battery and too broad and that it must be adapted a special hullB700BE (XL) Battery for Samsung GT-I9205 Galaxy Mega (6400mAh, Black) Extra Capacity Battery (Electronics) The Tournes screws are poor quality and too big for the Apple screws (risk of damage) the fragile plasticKit 7 Disassembly Tools for iPhone 3G 3GS 4 and 4S (Electronics) not working well and too smallDURAGADGET Mini Bluetooth Wireless Keyboard for Tablet Samsung Galaxy Tab (7.0) WiFi P3110 and Samsung Galaxy Tab 2 (7.0) P3100 - Portable and Practical (Electronics) none too small and too fragileY-BOA 1 pc Fillet Linen Bag Delicate Laundry Wash Bag-protector Designed For Bras / Lingerie Sensitive / Tights (Dia.19cm * H 14cm) a little too sweet and too hard and stick to the very teeth, pack was openHaribo cherry coke 735,159 VE150 (Food & Beverage) too wide and too longSailing Aqua Shoes Water Sport Shoes (Misc.) Unfortunately, far too big and too heavy.Diesel Men's Watch Chronograph Quartz XL Mega Chief Leather DZ4281 (clock)