Price / performance is victorious, magnetic mount not conform VDS, LED available and flashes every 40 seconds

Price / performance is victorious, magnetic mount not conform VDS, LED available and flashes every 40 seconds

Smartwares 10-year VdS smoke detectors with magnetic holder, set of 3, Q certified RM218SET / 3 (tool)

Customer Review

As a landlord, we now need to retrofit some homes with smoke detectors. As part of this I am with Amazon on this product here (Smartwares people smoke detectors) and the competing product "Ei Electronics Ei650" encountered that have yet tasted 6 weeks before both about 20 per smoke detector.
Was important to us that there is a smoke detector with Litiumbatterie so that we "up to 10 years" have our peace - especially since every smoke detector should be replaced after 10 years.

Positive about this product should be mentioned:
+ Instructions in sufficient detail and in German
+ Simple initial start-up (5 seconds on the push button)
+ Easy installation with the magnets
+ Visually neutral / response (glossy white)
+ Price (only about 18 per smoke detector incl. Magnet)

Apart from the magnetic holder, any modern smoke detectors should fulfill the above points.

Unfortunately, the deduction of three stars comes about due to the following disadvantages:
- The smoke detector has a red "I-live-even" LED (more about below)
- The LED lights up every 40 seconds (!)
- In the article description does not, but probably mentioned on the packaging: The magnetic mount is _not_ VDS compliant

Most disturbs me the LED, because I have read the item description exactly (and the LED is not mentioned there) have studied the photos and especially, where also no LED can be seen. This is because the LED is designed so that it shines through the cover (which has the advantage, at least, that the light is highly insulated and scattered, and not the room briefly lit). The smoke detector must be "the people" by law now have in the bedroom - who would want to see a flashing smoke detector? In addition, the LED still lights up every 40 seconds! All have 3-5 minutes, if at all necessary, also passed. The light, as I said, is very weak but especially noticeable when the smoke alarm has roughly reading with dim light in the visual field.

This does not deserve the title of "people's smoke detector" for me the product, especially not because being advertised with this easy and practical magnet assembly that is not certified VDS.

Those are in my view very serious shortcomings, which I now see, however, away and the smoke detector (about 20 pieces in total) will so operate because of the price. Because unfortunately the competing product has become more expensive by 40-50% in the last few weeks (now 28 per smoke detector, without magnet, for us in total over 100).

Genial 7 51 Rank: 5/5
December 6
Daryl Dixen figure Rank: 5/5
April 15
Very good foundation Rank: 4/5
March 9
Some things less Rank: 2/5
May 23
right product 1110 Rank: 4/5
May 6

Related Reviews


Product does not conform to the image and faulty contact.Belkin Headphone Splitter F8V234eaWHT-APL Audio Splitter (Accessory) Price-performance ratio is great, but not rotatable by 180 °Systafex SY-13014 Swivel TV wall mount to 139.7 cm (55 inches) for LCD / LED / 3D Plasma (Accessories) Price / performance ratio, sound for me notPioneer S-HS100 5.1 speaker system (150 Watts Maximum load) (Electronics) Top Price / performance - but phone encryption is not possible!Honor 6 Smartphone (5 inch touchscreen, Octa-Core, 3GB RAM, 16GB ROM, 13MP main camera, 5MP front camera, LTE CAT6, Android 4.4, EmotionUI 2.3) Black (Wireless Phone) Best price / performance ratio with socket 1150 boards, with Intel GB LAN and ramdisk software!Asrock H87 PRO4 1150 motherboard socket LGA (ATX, Intel H87, DDR3 memory, 6x SATA III, USB 3.0) (Personal Computers) Price performance is good but otherwise not very perfecktHolzmann KAP 255 XJL tensile miter saw (Misc.) Top price-performance, easy installation, optical Ok, not fitSlim USB DVD CD Blu Ray Drive Housing Case external SATA USB 2.0 (Electronic) Super price / performance ratio - more you do not need.Electric blanket heating blanket bedspread Warmer Wärmeunterbett heat mat mat Price / performance ratio was super! 0.5W in stand-by, and about 10W when the LED lights upLED floodlight with motion sensor 10W Not the best 50W LED Gu10 spare, but the one with the best price / performance ratioOSRAM LED reflector PAR1650 5,3W (50W replacement) warm white dimmable GU10 (household goods) Super product - not to beat price-performance !!Asus 1215B 30.7 cm (12.1 inches) Netbook (AMD E-450, 1.6GHz, 2GB RAM, 500GB HDD, ATI HD 6320) matte black (Personal Computers) Keeps its promises - Price / Performance Top - Be careful when the screws!Nanook steel mailbox Mailbox - Brushed - 38 x 30 x 11 cm (HxWxD) - with newspaper compartment Good price / performance ratio 12Sony HDR-CX240 HD Flash Camcorder (Full HD, Exmor R CMOS sensor, 2.2MP, BIONZ image processor X) (Electronics) TOP price / performance ratio without qualitative lossesbooEy® 2x Controller Battery Pack for Xbox 360 4800mAh with charging cable Black (Video Game) Unbeatable price / performanceAmazonBasics Microfiber Cleaning Cloths, 24 pieces (Automotive) Very good device with high-end features of this price / performance ratioPanasonic DMP-BDT700EG 3D Blu-ray player (Miracast, 2x HDMI, wireless LAN, SD card slot, DLNA, USB) (Electronics) Excellent price / performance ratio 3 2Olympus OM-D E-M10 system camera (16 megapixels, Live MOS Sensor, True Pic VII processor, fast AF system, 3-axis VCM image stabilizer, Full HD, HDR) body only (Electronics) Price-Performance Top 1 190CamCase Lifestyle bag for digital cameras, cell phones, keys and makeup (Luggage) Price / performance TOP !!! Attention - New info to hum or noise ...Logitech Z506 5.1 Speaker System Black (Personal Computers)