Quite good, but not fish nor fowl

Quite good, but not fish nor fowl

BenQ MS517 DLP Projector (3D, contrast 13000: 1, SVGA 800x600 pixels, 2800 ANSI lumens, HDMI, Smart Eco) (Electronics)

Customer Review

With much anticipation I have let myself in for the MS517 Beamer - football in large format, good BluRays with cinema feeling and the one or other entertaining 3D joke perhaps even with the kids. All this allows the BenQ, and at a very reasonable price - at least if you do not even need to buy more number of 3D shutter glasses, each again neatly beat Beech (50).

As the package quickly and neatly as shockproof came, I already experienced the first surprise: The projector comes across as high in spite of its price, at the same time it is very easy, so that even a ceiling mount with an optional bracket system will be possible without any problems. But with me it comes to test first on a small stepladder, as a projection surface is a white wall. Only a 1m long HDMI cable since I first at hand, and the first test may produce only a small picture. Before that however, is first commissioning. This is done with a few simple steps and self-explanatory - very good, but also necessary, because the printed Quick Guide is a joke, verbose is on CD.
Connected then the picture shines on the digital receiver for TV bright and well - class. However, due to the short cable to only small. So the true test must be carried out later, after my colleague has to be 10m HDMI cable borrowed.

This time is not only the digital TV Unitymedia, but also two DVDs (The Lord of the Rings - The Fellowship (Special Extended Edition, 4 DVDs) and Lottie and Lisa - Charlie & Louise: The music for the film - ballad piano..) a BluRay (Dark Shadows [Blu-ray]) and a 3D BluRay (The Smurfs (2D / 3D Version) [Blu-ray 3D]) tested - at a distance of about 4m. The picture is correspondingly large and magnificent promises entertainment, following positive experience / assessment leaves for BenQ MS517 with me:

+ Easy to connect
+ Light weight
+ Relatively good picture of Digital TV
+ Relatively good picture with BluRay
+ Neat 3D effects in 3D BluRay
Tidy usable + even with white walls as a projection

I should be satisfied so actually, you might think. But is offset by following more critical aspects:
- Only "relatively good picture in digital TV" because native resolution of 800x600px only
- Only "erhältnismäßig good picture with BluRay and 3D BluRay"
- A total of only satisfying light output in larger projections
- Incomprehensible poor representation og DVD movies - high noise levels mean that I interrupt the movies and not to look
- Loud fan that sucks really, if you sit next to it
- Very small remote control with unlit keys to offer more room for only mini-print and barely legible
Want mitgucken expensive acquisition of additional 3D glasses required, although his wife and two children -

Something so helpless I am faced with the device and think you pros and cons ... this is a device that I will continue to use? Will I make it either in the closet, build as needed and two cables across the room tension (HDMI and power) to every now and then look for something not even convinced me, but major soccer events for example, very cool is ? Or I'm going for even two cables on room corners and the ceiling embarrassed clean in order then even the projector firmly to mount on the ceiling, where it always visible and - if used - is not particularly attractive as a room decoration?
In both, I did not really fancy: For temporary use, I already know I'll often be too lazy to get him in the fixed installation I fear the effort and the office / conference room-like design of my living room.
For both simply not the image quality, for both the fan is too loud.

A look at the BenQ website shows that the MS517 is out there as "Education" device, not as "entertainment" device. Therefore are also a few originals faded (eg. Lines), so that you can write for example on a board easier. At school would certainly also the volume or the low-resolution setting not so disturbing as in the living room. But why he has for a 3D mode? Should we buy more glasses here for up to 30 students? Hardly likely!

Conclusion: What is the projector so thought? I do not know and do not understand it, feel it, therefore, a bit like "neither fish nor fowl". Satisfactory performance with all these advantages and disadvantages - to a very interesting base price make it for me to a conditional purchase recommendation - everyone should adopt the pros and cons to weigh well.

MUCH MUCH too expensive !!! Rank: 1/5
February 4
Good product 438 Rank: 3/5
December 3
IPhone very cute! Rank: 5/5
February 23
Very disappointed 228 Rank: 1/5
January 2
Actually a great idea Rank: 2/5
April 1
... And always "After Freud" Rank: 4/5
February 5

Related Reviews


Quite good, but not as good as the price would suggest.StilGut® Book Type Case without clip, leather case for Sony Xperia Z3 Compact, cognac (Wireless Phone Accessory) Quite good, but not massage brush!Denman D6, shampoo and carpet brush, Black (Health and Beauty) Quite good, but not suitable for all turntablesTeac MC-DV 250 compact system (electronic) quite good, but not outstanding, Forza 4 is just as good.Forza Motorsport 5 - Game of the Year Edition - [Xbox One] (Video Game) Article quite good but not exceptionalPhilips SHL9560 / 10 Headband headphones for MP3 Player (Electronics) Not bad, but neither fish nor fowlExplosion In My Heart (MP3 Download) The game is quite good, but not a high flyerWatchdogs (Bonus Edition) - [PlayStation 3] (Video Game) Quite good, but not a mega-hit.United We Are (MP3 Download) Basically quite good, but not perfectTractive GPS tracker for dogs and cats (Misc.) Quite good, but not perfect for very fair skinNivea Visage Q10 Plus Anti-Wrinkle Colour Correction, moisturizer, 1er Pack (1 x 50 ml) (Health and Beauty) Quite good, but not yet matureiRiver - Story eBook Reader 2GB (Electronics) Quite good, but not a substitute for a realPhilips ECO FC6148 / 01 Mini Vac (bagless, 10.8V Li-ion battery, 2-stage) gray (household goods) Quite good but not as good as its predecessorsAshes of the Wake (Audio CD) Quite good but not optimalAir Purifier B-668 with dual HEPA filtration system ozone ionizer up. 40m² or 100m³ (Misc.) Quite good, but not as original!Avanto Platic Back Cover battery cover / battery cover with brushed aluminum for Samsung Galaxy Note 2 / GT-N7100 and GT-N7105 - white / gray (Electronics) For the money, quite good, but not a summer gloveUltra Sport gloves with touch function (Sports Apparel) The idea is quite good but not quite authenticSoul tracks-the Kaisermania Edition (Audio CD) Quite good, but not outstanding soundYamaha YDP-161 Digital Piano (40 Watt) Rosewood (Electronics) OK, not fish nor fowlCarlo Cokxxx hookers 3 (Audio CD)