Visionary basic idea.  The implementation, however, is unconvincing

Visionary basic idea. The implementation, however, is unconvincing

The Man in the High Castle (Penguin Modern Classics) (Paperback)

Customer Review

What if Roosevelt would have been 1933 not shot? If the Second World War then ended before 1947 and might have the Axis powers and not Germany and Japan won the war and divided the world among themselves? That question was raised of the author Hawthorne Abendsen in his novel 'The Grasshopper Lies heay', which is of course forbidden in Fortress Europe, in the Japanese occupied territories and in the neutral, small, American buffer zone between the German and Japanese occupation area but is a best seller ,

Much of this novel by Philip K. Dick is a classic alternate history novel, of course, treated still hot topic especially Nazi Germany in the 1960s. Here, unfortunately, all the then dominant prejudices and stereotypes about German served: cynic, perfectionists, soulless, arrogant, blond ...

"'[' ...] They're Cynics with utter faith. It's a sort of brain defect, like a lobotomy'that maiming Those German psychiatrists do as a poor substitute for psychotherapy. '"
"'They're all committing incest, [...'] That's Why They, Those elite SS fairies, have that angelic simper, That blond baby like innocence;. They're saving for Mama Themselves Or for Each Other '.."
. "'They identify with God's power and believe They are godlike That is Their basic madness They are overcome by some archetype;. Their egos have expanded psychotically so thatthey can not tell Where They begin and the godhead leaves off It is not hubris. not pride; it is inflation of the ego to its ultimate'confusion between him who worships and That Which is worshiped. '"

By the way Philip K. Dick seems to have been a fan of James Joyce and desperately trying to imitate his Ulysses. He describes a few days in this world from different angles at different locations. Your actions affect each other, even if they never meet. The actions are in part simply trivial.
-Mr. Frink, Jew, divorced, loses his job and makes with a former colleague a Schmuckatelier on.
-Frinks Ex-wife Juliana Frink, judo teacher in the buffer zone, meets an attractive Italians and goes with him on trips
-Rudolf Wegener, a German agent, makes contact with the Japanese side.
-Robert Childan, 38 years old, an art dealer genuine American war art, discovered in his assortment fakes.
-Mr. Tagomi and his wife, clients of Robert Childan.

In return, the author has used the more of interior monologue and writes for the most part also the text in this abrupt, choppy manner:
'' Only Way is this, he DECIDED. He felt grim, even desperate. Go to Ray Calvin. Confront him. Insist did he pursue matter back to source. Maybe he is innocent, too. Maybe not. '"
The protagonists seem all rather broken altogether to speak English.

On top of that Philpp K. Dick repeatedly scatters German sentences. It was at that time but well beneath the dignity of the author to have a native speaker check the grammar and spelling. The Germans passages are almost all flawed in one way or another, whether it be grammatically distorting (as the good, instead of the good), formulations that would so never use and umlauts are already a matter of luck.

Why, then, this book is a visionary classics of science fiction? There is a simple explanation: The basic idea of ​​this novel: The I Ching.
It's not just about an alternate history. The point is that Philip K. Dick in this novel the principle, the idea of ​​parallel worlds designs long before quantum physicist should come up with this idea and they would scientifically substantiate. By means of the I Ching, the prophet from Mount Hawthorne Abendsen information out of this parallel universe and publish it as a novel, this world exists somewhere. Philip K. Dick himself wrote this novel with the help of the I Ching and also leaves its protagonists regularly consult the oracle, Philip K. Dick So even the Abendsen Hawthorne, our world.
The creators of Matrix translated therefore Philip K. Dick with the figure of her oracle in the Matrix trilogy, a monument, because they also give the Oracle between the two realities, the world out there and the matrix.

Seen lays down the basic idea of ​​the novel is an important science fiction foundation, creates a visionary basic idea. The implementation, however, is unconvincing.

Note to Cover: Usually I find it ridiculous when someone leaves out on the cover of a book. Here I have to point out that one should read the book in any case to air travel. The swastika is illegal in Germany against the law and an acquaintance has therefore already once an American novel because of the title picture at customs confiscated (Harris: Vatherland).

Nothing special 7 Rank: 3/5
July 22
Bel cases, but some doubt on the product SAMSUNG originality Rank: 3.0 stars out of 5 "height =" 12 "border =" 0 "/>/5
January 6
geniale but be careful! Rank: 4/5
December 6
Really good CE1 Rank: 5/5
January 27

Related Reviews


Divided opinion basic idea well, implementation flawed.Battlefield Hardline - [PlayStation 4] (Video Game) The poorer the scope of the implementation, however, better Wii Sports ResortSports Champions (Move erforderlich) (Video Game) Good basic idea, bad implementationIbili 780040 Coffee capsule dispenser for Nespresso (household goods) Good basic idea poorly implementedZenker 7515 Pizza Baker Set 4 pcs. Teflon® (household goods) INNOVATIVE basic idea AT THE strictly linear STORY AND GAMEPLAY UNAUSGEWOGENEM FAILSMurdered: Soul Suspect - [PlayStation 4] (Video Game) Great game idea, but weaknesses in the implementation of in gameRavensburger 00526 - Tiptoi: The Sunken logic country (without pin) (Toy) Great idea but it falls short on the implementationkicker (App) Good idea - somewhat tricky in the implementationWalimex Pro 2-in-1 reflector / light umbrella (84 cm) white (accessory) The idea great, implementation not wellRavensburger 00514 - tiptoi®: journey through the seasons (without pin) (Toy) Good idea - in the implementation hapert there anything elseSanDisk Eye-Fi Secure Digital High Capacity Card SDHC 4GB Memory Card (optional) Good idea, but the implementation is from hakelig to buggy.The Crew [PC Download] (Software Download) INNOVATIVE basic idea, ON STRICTLY LINEAR STORYBOARD FAILSMurdered: Soul Suspect [PEGI] (Video Game) Plenty of good ideas poorly implementedThe Guild 2: Renaissance (computer game) Idea beautiful, implementation rather weakAnker® PU Leather Case Cover for Google Nexus 5 - Combo Case Wallet - Card Case - Wallet Case - grip as sheepskin - with PC bowl - Multi angle stand (Wireless Phone Accessory) Good basic idea with potential for expansion1 Solfeggio - learn music read music (App) great idea - catastrophic implementationLenovo Yoga Tablet 2-10 25.7 cm (10.1 inches) FHD IPS Tablet (Intel Atom Z3745, 1,86GHz, 2GB RAM, 16GB of internal memory, touch screen, Android 4.4) Platinum (Personal Computers) Great idea unfortunately implemented mediocreBest of (Audio CD) Good idea, moderately implementedF1 Race Stars - [PlayStation 3] (Video Game) Lots of potential, only in the implementation hapert itObsidian (Lux A Novel) (Paperback)