The negative ratings in a similar product Anschlussverdoppler Equip Cat. 5e (RJ45 plug - 2x RJ45 jack) I can not confirm. I think here you have not previously possibly misinformed.
It is important to be that two of these products used and that the whole does not replace a switch / router. It uses in order to allow through the same cable line a further connection only (in a normal 100BaseT network) unused 4 wires out. (At the other end of the two ports must of course be connected to a switch / router.)
For the price, the product is great and I can save the operation of another power eater -> Green IT :-)