But yes - it really contains coal. However, the product puts a lot of dye CI 77499 it -> a dye the color "Black". Therefore, the product has its color. One should not be fooled and think that the cleansing gel color comes from the coal. But the extra dye has an unpleasant drawback: it occupies the sink with a grayish veil. Ie: sink again briefly rinse / clean, otherwise remains of gray veil. Is a little cumbersome, each time having to additionally waste water to eliminate the color remains of Cleansing gels.
For the cleansing gel alone: 3 stars. Because of the gray haze in the sink, the L'Oreal only caused because you want to pretend with a dye, coal-color the customer, but there's still a star deduction.
Conclusion: 2 stars.