Excellent reading, for non-players as for passionate players

Excellent reading, for non-players as for passionate players

Reality is Broken: Why Games Make Us Better and How They Can Change the World (Paperback)

Customer Review

This is a book on gambling. It is specifically focused on video games and Internet games, but 99% of the consideration will apply (and are enforced by the auteuse) to all the games since antiquity, through the games around a table and including the role plays. The auteuse speaks from his point of view, that of a game designer who participated in some of the most creative video games, the most "story oriented", and most innovative of recent years. But his references depart from Herodotus (and return there at the end) through the medieval and historical ancient games, ending with modern games, not just video games.

The aim of the author is that the games make us better, improve our mood, our happiness, our abilities, our links with communities (real or virtual), our creativity and our sense of accomplishment and achievement.

She is very convincing in most subjects (maybe I am a public foregone?).

There are some less convincing in his argument sides, including the self-help / personal development side and the side "harness the power of games to change the world", to use the motivation created by the games for real goals, while which makes the power of games is precisely that nothing the "harness", IMHO, not for personal reasons (as she suggests doing it in the first part), for collective reasons (as it suggests in the second part). In my vision there is no second thought in the act of playing and the games are not explicitly linked to a result other than the game, enhancing learning, work creativity or strategy are side-effects, not targets imho .. (but that's my point, not that of the auteuse).

The chapter on "alternate reality games" is interesting (games whose top is the real world and that fit into the life of every day, where players are therefore necessarily mixed in the crowd with non-players) . She briefly mentions Killer (in Europe) also called Assassins (the US), which is the ancestor and for me is the origin of ARG; but cites full I did not even know existed. Again, the intentional manipulation side of the game seems to me less convincing than the virtues "natural and unpremeditated" the game (she cites many examples of alternate reality games designed for lots of different purposes: to heal faster when you are recovering from a serious illness and can not get all its capabilities, to promote the establishment of social links between foreign and promote re-socialization of anonymous urban spaces, to increase his own happiness, or motivation screw vis a particular type of task).

For the (ex) RPG player I am, there is a pair of errors of taste in his book, she mentions the role plays about as videos and games MMORPG (online). And when talking about collaborative games rather than competitive cites four or five times new forms of sports games, and still no sign of our good old RPG, yet well now firmly established in the field of collaborative games, imaginative play and games "story oriented" since the beginning ...

In the second part, which roughly describes how to hire players to save the real world by and large, there are too many words like "harness" "tap into the collective energy" "reap the benefits" that vex me; this is based on "economy of the commitment" an economy of socialization positive feelings and emotional reward and in terms of happiness which sometimes has some hints capitalism and market economy, even if for California, it is rather impressive by his will (with a Christian connotation?) to change the world, to mend the social ties, to bring out the best of every human being, and to find an alternative to the all-capitalist world and all- market before it will lead us, like lemmings consumers toward a crowded world, devoid of essential resources and wall for a global conflagration disasters.

So it is rather in the last part that I struggle to continue to follow: with all the qualities she attributes to the game, she thinks it is necessary to turn the global and major problems in games; because as a game, you better learn a framework functioning and constraints, deeper and more motivating; because as a game, it releases creativity and leads to very unexpected and highly innovative solutions, which often prove to be the most productive solutions.

I am willing to follow up the implementation of "protein folding" playstation 3 console that has a graphics card with a large computing power, perfectly suited to the management structures in 3D. Two programs "folding proteins" have been adapted to it. The first program simply uses the computing power of the game console when not in use as voluntary users donate their computing time. The other program is an interactive game where the user folds the protein itself. The interactive game having arrived 3 times new findings and never achieved by the automatic program, and 5 times as good results ... The game and the voluntary donation of time machine with both reached peaks of participation public, indicating a motivating players to participate in the solution of real problems.

By cons, when the game is seen as a way to motivate the whole of humanity to the problem of global warming, hunger in the world, the end of oil, increased competition for drinking water , education and all the ills of the world, I tell myself I'm going to put myself in the games 'escapism' and take a subscription MMORPG public ...

Anyway, this is a very intelligent and very eloquent auteuse, who often impressive clarity of thought and an equally impressive clarity in the statement of his ideas.

Finally the right bag found ... Rank: 5/5
November 2
Easy to use 7 1 Rank: 5/5
January 15
Reimbursed for not working Rank: 1/5
October 31

Related Reviews


Excellent read for organic farming or gardeningOne-straw Revolution: Introduction to Natural Farming (Paperback) Excellent reading for those who have eyes to read.Talking with Angels, complete edition (Paperback) Excellent reading for the preparation of a US -Southwest - TravelA Guide to the Natural Landmarks of Arizona (Photographing the Soutwest) (Paperback) Excellent artwork, must-see and must-read for the George RR Martin fansThe Hedge Knight: The Graphic Novel (A Game of Thrones) (Paperback) Perfect reading light and excellent value for money!Wedo 2541001 mobile LED reading lamp with Black batteries (Office Supplies) The master stroke - even or especially for passionate amateur filmmakersSony NEX-VG20EHB Full HD Camcorder (Flash, 16 megapixels, Exmor CMOS Sensor, 7.6 cm (3 inches) touch display) incl. 18-200mm Lens (Electronics) Excellent value for money, easy Hackintosh, modern cheapGigabyte - GA-B85M-D3H - 1.0 - motherboard - micro ATX - LGA1150 Socket - B85 - USB 3.0 - Gigabit LAN - onboard graphics (CPU required) - HD Audio (8-channel) (Personal Computers) An excellent book for young audiencesAnimal tatoo, Volume 1: The four elected (Paperback) Excellent collection for children 1The pool (Hardcover) Excellent book for the supply of seniorsThe power of senior citizens: The first of vigilance (Paperback) Excellent automatic for daily useInvicta 8926 Men's clock (clock) ID card reader (for new ones) SCMID card reader (for new ones) Reading for long and cold autumn eveningsMe Before You (Paperback) An excellent value for money !!!2GB Memory / RAM for Acer Aspire One D260 (DDR2) (Electronics) Must-Read for all Dystopienfans!Under the Never Sky (Under the Never Sky Trilogy, Volume 1) (Paperback) Good card reader for CF cardsIntegral Single Slot USB Compact Flash Card Reader (Electronics) Excellent value for money - TOP UNITXoro HRK 8750 CI + Digital Cable Receiver (HDTV, DVB-C, CI +, HDMI, SCART, PVR-ready, 2x USB 2.0) (Electronics) Excellent value for money, attention and doubled the tablet thicknessLeather Case Cover for Samsung-Galaxy Tab 10.1 P7510, P5110 Tab 2 - black Excellent tool for everyday lifeJawbone Bluetooth Bracelet with UP24 (Sport)