We were allowed to try out the Felix Crunchy & Soft as part of product testing. Our conclusion is that we would not use the food as food for our cat. As a snack or treat in between, it is quite ok. The cats eat very happy but lost after a few days, interest in the food. We suspect that it is because the main component of the feed is not meat but grain is. Positive is the lining has no strong odor and the packaging is resealable. We would feed reuse but as mentioned just as a snack.