Good, but too late and too prescriptive for my taste.

Good, but too late and too prescriptive for my taste.

Clean Code: A Handbook of Agile Software Craftsmanship (Paperback)

Customer Review

After Complete Code and, to a lesser extent, Craft Code, one wonders how an author can enrich development practice with a new book. Code Complete would he some flaws?

Not really. Or in regard to parallelism and some other specific and mainly related to Java points.

I read this book in two or three days (I'm pretty passionate about it). Here's what I think:

- Most - if not all boards are legitimate. However, they are mostly already widely discussed in Code Complete and Craft Code.

- The author seems so sure of himself that he rarely gives references. Although Code Complete is based largely on serious studies, Clean Code is first and foremost based on the aesthetics of its author. When the first said, "You should do this because studies have shown that ...", the second says "Do this. And that is why I think it's better ...". The impression left by the tone is rather unpleasant.

- Developers who do not use Java will remain somewhat unsatisfied. Although Code Complete attempts to be agnostic in terms of language, Clean Code resolutely Java. That said, we can easily adapt to C # and VB.NET.

- Agile Development: the word is fashionable, we use everywhere to sell some more. Clean code is not agile than are Code Complete and Craft Code. I even thought he was a little less, but it is an impression.

I put 4 stars because too few computer scientists read that kind of book, however, essential. If you have any books on the subject, read Code Complete. Then either, Craft Code Clean Code or (my preference from the first - the author does not give the idea of ​​innate knowledge).

That said, if you do not have access to the first two, Clean Code is a very good book.

Disappointed, poor quality. Rank: 1/5
May 31
Transmitter capriceux Rank: 2/5
November 13
What to remember Rank: 5/5
December 2
Bag "has everything" Rank: 4/5
September 22
Detailed Map 1 Rank: 3/5
January 21
A true masterpiece. 3 Rank: 5/5
December 5

Related Reviews


Good, but too small for FZ200 and accessoriesMaxampere max705_01 camera bag for compact system camera with orange lining black (Accessories) In principle good, but too noisy for usSuper Multi blind shutters Motor Gurtwickler f. Roller shutter blinds no Rollotron (Misc.) Very good but too white (for me)LED MR16 (GU5.3) 12V 4.5 W (370 lumens - the equivalent of 45 watts) 45 degree cool white 4000K (Cool) Very good - but too small for mePentax K-5 II digital SLR camera (16.3 megapixels, 7.6 cm (3 inch) screen, Live View, SAFOX X autofocus, HDMI, USB 2.0) incl. 18-55mm WR Kit (Electronics) Good but too big for tablets 6 "Port Designs Mandalay Protective Case for ebook / iPad / Tablet PC 6 "(Accessory) Good quality but too dull for my tasteKwmobile® 3x protective film for MAT ANTI-GLARE screen with anti-fingerprint effect for Samsung Galaxy Note 10.1 2014 Edition P600 QUALITY (Electronics) good, but too small for Alienware M11xDicota PerfectSkin notebook sleeve for 29.4 cm (11.6 inches) black (accessories) Good, but too wide for lean children ...Twins Baby - Boys Shirt 2 Pack (Textiles) Good, but too loud for real movie experience at homeBenQ MW526 DLP Projector (3D over HDMI, WXGA, 1280 x 800 pixels, 3200 ANSI lumens, contrast 13000: 1, VGA, Smart Eco) White (Electronics) good but too small for 6 hensHenhouse Estaires GREY grayer park (Miscellaneous) Good, but too slow for the Samsung NX3000 system camera!Samsung Memory 32GB microSDHC Class 6 Memory Card Standard Memory Card (up to 24MB / s data transfer rate) with SD adapter (accessory) Good but too long for meLeather Belt 3cm wide black! About length to 180 cm (Textiles) Good, but too warm for interiorsST3 Polar M-XL costume polar bear costumes polar bear costume costumes Carnival Carnival (Toys) Pocket good, but too small for iPhone 6 Pluszkiosk® Pannier Frame Bag top tube top tube bag Apple iPhone 6 (Gr.L) Blue (Electronics) Good, but too expensive for the officeCanon PGI-5BK Original Black Ink Cartridge (Office Supplies) Good but too expensive for a plastic tipOlympus EP-10 wide Eyecup for E-M5 (Accessory) Film good but too small for the Lumix DMC-TC613 x atFoliX protector Panasonic Lumix DMC-TZ61 Screen Protector - FX antireflective glare-free (electronic) Bag is good but too small for normal lensesNikon CF DC5 SLR Camera Case D600 (accessory) Good but too bad for foodIcy Box 11584 External Hard Drive Enclosure for 4 3.5 "SATA I / II / III / eSATA USB 3.0 Black (Accessory)