Good concept, but not the optimal tours saddle

Good concept, but not the optimal tours saddle

Selle SMP TRK Gel Man (equipment)

Customer Review

I drive quite a lot of bicycle (already 5800 km in 2014; as of 12 July) and am years of satisfied drivers Brooks leather saddles on my bikes (currently models "Conquest" and "B67 Aged"). I recently discovered but the "Selle SMP TRK gel" seat in a bicycle shop and me - due to the very interesting acting concept - get carried to this saddle time to buy a trial basis.
The manufacturer promises much good stuff:
The central channel is to prevent any bruising or compression of the pelvis, avoid the top with "eagle's beak" shape bruising of the genitals, protect the rear lowering the coccyx against bruises and bumps.
According on the packaging "the most comfortable solution for demanding touring bikers".
Now it is not so, that I would be unhappy with my Brooks saddles in any way or me so far would have to complain about bruised pelvis or genitals. There would therefore be no reason to meet these leather saddles unfaithful. But perhaps I miss a whole new, ultimate comfort feeling here? After all, I'm after a tour of about 100 km, which corresponds to me a good 5 hours drive to the trekking, but time to get off the bike very happy because so slowly makes the butt then also with a Brooks saddle noticeable.
Should the Selle SMP here so still a number have been better?
My experience with plastic gel saddles saw in the past, however, quite different: The superficially comfortable and soft gel saddle always turned out a very short time to be extremely uncomfortable out. Pain in the tailbone, numbness in the genital area, burning buttocks. For Sunday Biergarten cyclists perhaps ok, for longer trips but absolutely not suitable.
So let's see what this one has to offer, especially as (according to package 79 Euro MSRP) yes certainly expect a quality product at a price of about 60 euros. Well, the Brooks saddles cost all again significantly more, but most plastic gel saddles - are for much cheaper - and to such it is indeed now time here.
After two tours of about 100 km length with the Selle SMP TRK gel the result is now clear:
It is in fact an ordinary and relatively road proven saddle - to the long-distance comfort of a Brooks he does not come close, however. Specifically: after a good 3 hour drive the saddle but then began to be quite uncomfortable. The typical "plastic gel saddle symptoms", as described above, but in fact are completely eliminated. It's more of the same feeling of a general pressure on the rump of what I know of the Brooks saddles - but here it takes just some time earlier.
The saddle is therefore not bad - but the best is the enemy of good, we can see here. So I have now yet again the Conquest Brooks leather saddle mounted and looked forward today with a renewed 100 km tour with Brooks about the actual "comfortable solution for touring bikers".
Can I use the "Selle SMP TRK gel" saddle now recommend or not?
Yes, if:
- You do not want to spend so much money as a Brooks leather saddle
- You do not want to enter only some time the new saddle before it is convenient (a main disadvantage of the leather saddles)
- You want a relatively weatherproof saddle which has not or hardly be maintained
- You're looking for a saddle that does not rub off even when wet
- You drive not very long trips, or I can thoroughly recommend it to a leather saddle.
Overall I give therefore 3 stars = "Not bad."

Progress everywhere you look! Rank: 5/5
April 13
I liked BUT ... 1 Rank: 3/5
September 18
perfect 1 3260 Rank: 5/5
June 8
My choice finally. Rank: 4/5
December 20
Good product 1449 Rank: 5/5
February 5

Related Reviews


Good concept, but not to the pointParrot AR. Drone 2 Remote Quadricopter Blue (Electronics) A very good result but not the maximum score because too many jerks !!The Walking Dead: Season 2 (Video Game) thought good concept, but not finishedLowepro LP36576 Transit Camera Case (250 AW) (Electronics) Good concept, but not 100% ....Logitech K830 wireless illuminated keyboard with touchpad Living Black (Personal Computers) Keyboard of good quality, but not the driver.Perixx PX-3200FR, Retro Gaming Keyboard eclaire Programmable - 12 Macros with 3 Profiles Users - 7 Colours Retro-lighting - 27 Anti-ghosting keys - QWERTY (Electronics) Good product, but not the one I orderedLeather case with belt clip Case Cover Protector Pouch for Samsung Galaxy SIII S3 / S2 Galaxy SII / Samsung GT-E1050 / GT S5260 / S8600 Samsung Wave 3 GT / Samsung S5230 / Player One / HTC One V / Samsung S5230 / Sony Xperia U / Samsung S3350 T / Sony Xpera Ray / Blackberry Curve / Motorola Atrix / Motorola DEFY / HTC ONE S (Wireless Phone Accessory) Good game - but not the expected HitDeus Ex: Human Revolution (Video Game) A very good game, but not the hoped-for top PopsMafia II (uncut) (Video Game) A good collection but not the best!Unforgettable (New Version) (Audio CD) Very good product, but not the right to make mistakes.tinxi® Screen Protector Film Tempered Glass Screen Protector Google Nexus 5 optimal and ultra hard protective tempered glass screen (Electronics) good atmosphere, but not the style ...Faceless Killers (Pocket Book) Good stylus, for the university but not the optimal solutionWacom CS-160 Bamboo Stylus solo 3rd generation, touch screen stylus for iPad, iPhone, Android tablets, smartphones, with replaceable Pen Carbon tip, gray (Accessories) Good concept but not quite suitable for the MacBook Pro 15 ''ALIAS protective silicone keyboard for MacBook Pro 15.4 VETERANS & 17 " Very good device, but not the right one for me. Best DAB receiver!Auna Connect 150 Design Lan Radio Internet Radio Wifi Radio alarm clock in aluminum-wood design (USB, Lan, DAB / DAB +, FM, RDS, 2 alarm times, Sleep timer, remote control, AUX) black-brown (Electronics) Musso good novel, but not the bestCentral Park (Paperback) Good product, but not the best ...G4 LED Bulb 1.8W to 20W 12V 160 Lumen 6000K Light of Day (Kitchen) Good product but not the best onePhilips Avent Listen Baby - Day and Night Video SCD603 / 00, max: 150 m (Baby Care) Good idea but not the best solutionUltra Slim Aluminum Bumper for Samsung Galaxy S5 SM-G900F - Original Saxonia Metal Case Aluminum Shell Phone Case Cover Case Cover only 8 grams / Silver (Electronics) Good equipment, but not the best qualityTELME C115 (seniors phone with emergency call function and FM radio, desktop charger) (Electronics)