Lack of snow and ice, we have the water resistance now only at the sink tested: held a few minutes in cold water, happily moves the finger and watched what happened. Result: no water intrusion, everything stays dry and warm.
The design is attractive and fits in purple also to our other winter equipment. Because the price is currently reduced from Amazon, the gloves have a very good value for money - I would give them give preference due to the high quality materials and flawless processing over yet cheaper models from a department store or even from discounters.
The only downside is the small (very small) buckle, with which you can connect the two gloves for storage or transportation for me. That they would not have to use (as another reviewer said), I can not confirm. Fiddly it is due to the tiny size but already, especially when opening - nothing for thick fingers. Also, it seems not very stable. It used to be used for something like mini-carabiner made of iron, but that would now probably not fit for plastic design, or it would simply cost more. Even a small defect, but not decisive for the war, so good 4 stars.