Foo Fighters fans that I can somehow understand manifest itself negatively these days about the new album. I am also a fan since the first album and have always believed that Foos have always improved with every album. So One by one was a long time so the absolute favorite album for me because it was so varied and demanding. Many of the tracks have really opened up to me after months. The latest work of the guys to know Dave Grohl from the beginning to inspire! And perhaps even since the hook. The album is good - really good. But I doubt that it can inspire the fans long. For this purpose, it simply lacks depth and creativity. The rock record sounds as a unified whole and does so well in the long run boring. Also would have done quite well for 2 to 3 more titles, the disc. I give it 5 stars because it is currently being compared to other rock CDs just a really good record, and because the Acoustic CD is simply incredible. By contrast, the two previous albums, however, would get 6 stars from me. All not-yet-fans: she buys you! It can not hurt!