I use these eye make-up remover has developed over several years and can say that it reliably even waterproof make-up removed. I shake him more vigorously to mix the two phases and then pour it on a large cotton pad with roughened surface (there are in any drugstore). It does not leave all to oily film on the eyelids as it did so many favorable the drugstore own brand.
I am, however, noticed that it takes a lot more from the product, if only 1/4 (or less) is included. Presumably this is due to the changed ratio of oil and the remaining remover. - That's why only four stars.