At first I was skeptical because of the price of these taillights far below the original lights located. It is also not described clearly on the product side, whether it is the inner or outer taillights when VW Plus. At the price I have but then both ordered a trial basis. It is the outer (VW Plus 2009 -) and come from Thailand. I'm very satisfied. The exchange was real easy, though the fit is not super top notch, but sufficient for my needs and those things worked right away. All is well. and I will report here if that goes for longer.