Interesting idea, but covers only until 1984, poor structure and many spelling mistakes

Interesting idea, but covers only until 1984, poor structure and many spelling mistakes

Commodore: A Company on the Edge (Hardcover)

Customer Review

Commodore what part of my youth: When I was 13, I got my C64, Followed by at AMIGA a few years later. In That Time, you did not just buy a computer, but you chose sides: What nowadays is the fight between Apple / Windows / Linux what the fight between Commodore, Atari and Schneider (and the PC at a later point in time).

Despite of its fame, you never got a real inside look at what happened at the company, though. That's why this book Attracted me so much.

There are good and bad aspects about this book ...

... The idea itself is really good and makes for vivid images: interviews, background information and quotes from employees really give you a feeling for what happened at Commodore.

Unfortunately, the negative aspects outnumber the positive:
- The book only covers the years until 1984 Which is the pre-Amiga era. This is a big disappointment and a huge contradiction of what can be read in the synopsis! Keep that in mind if you are planning to buy this: Not a single word about the AMIGA product-family! At the end of the book the author announces the upcoming "Amiga" -Book ...
- The pictures are very poor, small and most of the time Completely irrelevant.
- Many, many spelling mistakes and missing words! (Remark: You can surely see That I'm not a native English speaker, but my reading is better than my writing and I know my english When I say there are lots of errors!) It Seems There was not of editor for this Product ...
- Poor structure: Many things and events are not Introduced at all and some are repeated every other page (eg Irving Gould and his role which never Introduced but suddenly he's there)

So, bottom line: I read it and It was not too bad, but confusing at times and I Wished the author would have condensed some of the many redundant remarks and adding the years 1985-1994 instead (as every buyer probably Expects after reading the synopsis anyway).

Does not work 51 Rank: 1/5
June 11
well done in many ways ... Rank: 5/5
March 1
Best price for cute key rings Rank: 4/5
January 17
Solid Python Exercise Book Rank: 5/5
February 24

Related Reviews


A large scratchcard interesting idea, but only 3.5 stars!Empire Merchandising 671 868 World Map Poster scratch card brand empire posters, scale 1: 6,75Mio. high quality print, size 61 x 91.5 cm (housewares) Innovative idea, but currently only durschnittliches device with even massive FW problems.Acer H7550BD 3D Full HD DLP projector (3,000 ANSI lumens, full HD 1920 x 1080 pixels, Bluetooth, Contrast 16,000: 1, Acer Hidden Port Design) White (Electronics) Cute 3rd-person adventure with an interesting idea but a short seasonMurdered: Soul Suspect - [Xbox One] (Video Game) Very interesting ideas, but also some weaknessesLightning Returns - Final Fantasy XIII - [PlayStation 3] (Video Game) Interesting idea but very flat and implemented with heavy defectsWatchdogs - [PC] (computer game) Interesting idea, but ...Skque® TPU Gel Cover Case with Screen Protector for Apple iPhone 4 4S (Cordless Phone) Nice idea, but unfortunately only for eight glasses and therefore a bit too expensiveAvery 62008 Living Preserving labels with freshness seal, various formats, white (Office supplies & stationery) VERY potent! But please only with anti-slip-PAD, and only for healthy people who want to train!Togu Togu Balance Board Level (equipment) Very interesting idea but still too weakSEBSON® E14 LED 3W filament Globe - cf. 25W bulb - 200 Lumen - E14 LED Filament warm white - LED lamp 160 ° Interesting idea but synthetic, too synthetic?The composition step by step. Visual-angle view Full-Impact. (Paperback) Very nice idea, but believes only partiallyOctone Notebook Care Set incl SWEEPER -. Microfibre TFT & LCD Screen Cleaning Cloth + Screen Protector PROTECTOR cloth + H2O Spray - for Macbook and PC monitor with 36cm (13 & 14 inch) diagonal - Eco Edition (office supplies & stationery) Funny idea, but not really suitable for all devices and not well implementedThe Inner World - The Puzzle (App) Pretty ... but many spelling mistakesBrinell Stick Single Action 240GB Memory Stick USB 3.0 Red Dot Winner 2013 carbon / black (Accessories) Good ideas but a lack of concreteEntrepreneur: 50 ideas to get you started! (Paperback) Certainly a good idea, but the qualityClassic Cantabile Guitar Stand GS Combined (universal stand, 3-way adjustable, footprint 32 x 29cm, padded support surface, rubber feet) Black (Electronics) Super ergonomic design, poor optical and mechanical engineeringWowpen Joy 3056 ergonomic optical mouse Vertical (800dpi, USB) Black (Personal Computers) Great idea but visually poor implementationHasbro A1650E24 - FurReal Friends Cuddles, my baby monkeys (Toys) Cool idea but poorly exploitedYou against me (Paperback) Very good idea but unfortunately poorly executedAA (Electronics)