Knotless small monitors with amazing skills and thoughtful details - The report of an (expected) Surprise!

Knotless small monitors with amazing skills and thoughtful details - The report of an (expected) Surprise!

Prodipe P46 MSC 4 inch coaxial monitor pair (Electronics)

Customer Review

First of all: A purchase I absolutely do not regret!
Initially I was skeptical because of the small chassis (10 cm), the small package volume, low power amplifier (2 x 20 W RMS) and the passive crossovers. To buy me eventually moved my interest in the point source due to the built-in coax, which moreover do not give the impression of cheap goods mediated (Kevlar cone and silk dome) and simply ingenious, ingeniously simple way of flat and tilted mode, as with large Wedge stage monitors.

My skepticism was quickly dissipated when I had taken the two Monitörchen in operation and hearing the first bars of music.
It pays just from when you buy from a manufacturer, the only pro audio produced devices because the bar is set right from the start higher and not slam the PC Brüllwürfel producer who also has PC mice in the portfolio and just happened to stop also speakers offering because people like the mitkaufen equal.

The processing of black, slightly textured, plastic foiled MDF is good to very good and is quite sufficient even for specialist. The two stand positions (flat and aufgewinkelt) are brilliantly simple and solved only work because of Koaxtreiber where the Aufstellausrichtung not care. The exterior is absolutely no frills, no-nonsense, but quite elegant and understated, therefore, nothing unnecessary prettified the clear form, or doing cheesy or pretentious to important. Form follows function rather than vice versa. The converters present themselves rather than simple, non-intrusive device work because as a design object. I like it, but this does not have any / each appeal.

Back at the left box, there is a terminal with 2 x RCA RCA L + R in, alternatively 1 x 3.5 mm stereo jack in, 1 x 3.5mm mono jack out for connecting the right box, which is passive, as well as a rotary potentiometer for the input sensitivity (volume).
All electronics incl. Power supply is located in the left box, on the right there is just another 3.5mm mono jack for connection to the amplifier output of the left box. The connection cable is included, as well as a Y-cable 2 x RCA to 3.5mm stereo jack, 12 self Dämpferpads as feet and a Manual. In both boxes is a small, simple, passive two-channel diverter.
This, however, results in a small, concept-related flaw: The built-in electronics, the left box is significantly heavier than the right and has a little less internal volume, thereby also the lower limit frequency of the left box should be slightly higher than in the right. Aurally I can not distinguish metrologically it's probably understandable, but probably negligible.
Here lies the biggest difference to professional nearfield monitors, which have usually active crossovers and separate amplifier units for bass and treble, as well as customization options in terms offer on frequency response and preparation, and this individually in each box. But that is a different league and their price level is also much higher, partly an order of magnitude.

Prodipe marketed the small MS4C though rather than active multimedia desktop speakers, because as near field, but I say they are actually suitable for both applications and worth considering.
After a short break-in period they quickly lose their initial sharpness that startled me shortly. Thus, if the spring stiffness and restoring forces of the drivers are once well established, they play pretty neutral, crystal clear, enjoyable directly and activating, the music dissolves entirely of the boxes positions and forms a remarkable stereo stage with good localization ability, for as tiny monitors. This requires close formation, best in arms reach and orientation of the boxes on the listening position, thanks to the two tilt angle options works for you all the time. The coaxial driver arrangement as point source works belonging installation close without the disadvantage migratory frequency components on the baffle conventional reusable systems.
But even the small home party, it does not take place in a gym so is amazingly quite properly, to tanzmotivierenden levels beschallbar, thanks to the low-distortion reproduction up in quite already hearing-impairing volume regions. However, the louder the strenuous and exhausting, with increasing sharpness and harshness play the small Prodipe on. But also very quiet levels are not quite your thing, it sounds pretty good, but with decreasing volume, they are increasingly thinner, paler, more boring, undifferentiated and squeezed in the overall sound, and does not in any case overwhelming dynamic capabilities continue to decline. The MS4C feel most comfortable in the medium volume level, where they are probably mainly operated. But that's physics.

Two peaks / resonances in the field at about 150 Hz (reflex tunnel and / or line-up on the table) and approximately between 1.8 kHz and 7 kHz (presumably responsible for the rest of sharpness) by up to + 6dB to fall, but since my hearing at high frequencies due to age already subsides, that bothers me the extra presence and treble less than the lightweight Dröhnanfälligkeit in kickbass area, but that is bearable and the equalizer entzerrbar (so you have a available). A deep but very short slump in the upper treble range is at 10.7 kHz, but can not really tell in practice mode and is apparently caused by the air gap of the low-midrange driver and tweeter surrounds (one of the few disadvantages of Koaxtreibers). I personally know this collapse just because studying a frequency Schriebs of a measurement test. Incidentally, all the manufacturer's instructions are included in this comprehensive and very serious test invariably confirmed or are partly even exceeded significantly, such as the amazing frequency response of 60 Hz - 32 kHz! (Test: Sound & Recording 02/2014) Here the French manufacturer Prodipe exaggerates so far, but communicates more conservative. He makes no secret of the fact that development and testing in France, the production but takes place in Asian mass producers - A beautiful, Chapeau!

Two small criticisms I have also, in terms of the equipment:
1) The speaker connection using a mono phone cable may perhaps still be electrically acceptable in the low performance level of 2 x 20 watts, allowing an unrivaled rapid connection of the two boxes, but also poses the problem that whenever the jack cable hardly substitute with sufficient cable cross section at market is available and is necessary a more remote distance between the two boxes, the handle for soldering iron when needed to make a longer connection cable itself. Anyway, this type of connection is absolutely not standard and I have also seen here for the first time.
Dear producers: Please change to eg the standard speaker terminals or -.klemmen, thus own individual stripping can be used. That can not cost the earth surely.

2.) speaker grilles are indeed in real nearfield monitors frowned upon because of their sound-influencing properties, but in boxing that will probably not be a priority in the studio and will occur more within the reach of small children and pets, simple, removable fabric-covered frame to protect the delicate membranes would be desirable. But I would also no less than 10 Euro price jump more, dear producers.

*** Can perhaps who take in French and translated in his review, so that the French manufacturer the two desires understands ;-) ***

Conclusion: A clear recommendation in this price range in terms of sound, clarity, directness and neutrality, absolutely can not be compared with the most similar and favorable Brüll.- Dröhnwürfeln from the crowded multimedia sector. The Aufstellflexibilität the small monitors is simply awesome and probably unique in this segment.
Who then dazugesellt an ordinary, active subwoofer to the couple in order to relieve the MS4C in Bass and support, let's say an 8-, 10-, or 12-inch model and opens up so the two octaves down further, while reflex tunnel MS4C with foam filled to minimize their Dröhnneigung the kick bass range that can take over the subwoofer to 150 Hz in any case, really could be really happy. But even without a real deep bass are the small monitors because of their transparent sound absolutely worth listening and enjoyable. I had not been, I would have to buy me smooth.

necklace dressage Rank: 3/5
May 11
Brother Printer Rank: 5/5
May 28
Perfect 355 1 Rank: 5/5
November 3
Pleasant 70 Rank: 3/5
December 13

Related Reviews


Extreme ingenious gameplay with amazing gameplay and technology classPlayStation 3 - Konsole Slim 160 GB (J-model) including Dual Shock 3 Wireless Controller (Console). A robust, practical headphones with super sound and meaningful detailsPhilips A3PRO / 00 OverEar foldable DJ Headphones (Electronics) Very good mattresses with good sun and Comfort at the best price !!!Dibapur®: Q 9 zones Orthopedic foam mattress (90x200) x ca.15,5 cm core with quilted double cloth cover about 16 cm Hardness: H2,5 (to about 110 kg) Dibapur®: Q stands for quality. Made in Germany (household goods) small box with amazing performance ...HAVIT® HV SK466BT Mini portable Bluetooth speaker, 8 hours of battery life (Black), St Patrick's Day (Wireless Phone Accessory) Great Smart TV with amazing 2D and 3D image and many featuresLG 55LM620S 140 cm (55 inch) TV (Full HD, triple tuners, 3D, Smart TV) (Electronics) Interesting, small camera with innumerable features and not perfect image qualitySamsung MV800 Digital Camera (16.1 megapixels, 5x opt. Zoom, 7.6 cm (3 inches) touch screen display) (Electronics) Elegant Full HD Monitor with poor ergonomics and configurabilityIiyama Prolite E2481HS-B1 61 cm (24 inch) widescreen TFT monitor (LED, HDMI, DVI, VGA, 2 ms response time) black (accessories) Class monitor with many strengths and weaknesses little!Samsung S27C750P 68.6 cm (27 inch) LED monitor (VGA, HDMI, 5ms response time) gloss black (Accessories) Very impressive, amazing images and thought provoking.Shark Water - If sharks die (Blu-ray) Aspiring coaches with style, charm and spirit conquers the Kalos region!Pokémon X (video game) Jack of all trades with classic qualities and technically on the amount of time?Fujifilm X20 Digital Camera (12MP, 4x opt. Zoom, Full HD, 7.1 cm (2.8 inch) LCD CMOS sensor, HDMI, image stabilization, USB 2.0) (Electronics) Irreplaceable for Prime members. With Kodi / XBMC and Sky Go the almost perfect Streaming StickFire TV Stick (Electronics) Perfect with RSI syndrome - and scrolls also the MACLogitech Marble Mouse Trackball Corded silver-red, USB port (Accessories) For small children well - just wear and price of the brush out of orderOral-B Stages Power Kids battery toothbrush, with Disney cars or -Prinzessin (Personal Care) Very good Vertikutierleistung and thoughtful details, only the catcher and the Assembly ...Einhell GE SA 1640 electric Verticutter fans (1600W, 40cm working width until 12mm working depth), Holm, 48L collection bag, incl. Fan roller, 3420590 (tool) Printers with lush amenities and deductions in the B-NoteEpson WorkForce WF-7525 multi-function device (scanner, copier, printer, USB 2.0) (Personal Computers) Small Ideapad with adequate skills for surfing etc.Lenovo S210 29.5 cm (11.6 inch HD LED) Slim Laptop (Intel Pentium 987, 1.5GHz, 2GB RAM, 320GB HDD, Intel HD Graphics, Touch Screen, Win 8) white (Personal Computers) Small card with great performance; and something more.SanDisk Extreme III SD 2GB SD Memory Card (optional) Small receiver with good reception and tidy imageDigital pearl.tv HD satellite receiver DSR-395U.SE with Full HD Player (Electronics)