Have the Collektion bought due to the many positive reviews to make my 10-year son with English Reading familiar. She stood for this intention out as unsuitable. The contents are mundane and boring for a 10th. Example: In the first story to Winny annoys you that you will not find her black cat in her black house. She conjures him a colorful coat in order to subsequently determine that it can most easily find their black cat in a colorful house. -THE END - .Dafuer the vocabulary (. Eg shiver, whiskers) and grammar (simple past, past perfect) in turn for primary school level right / too demanding. The illustrations are for my taste quite gloomy and the witch does not really appealing. For CDs, the slow rate of speech of the narrator is the positive side. The voice of the witch is shaky. My son said in an amused tone -if - that go him shaky ABRACADABRA powerfully on the nerves. Even my little son (4years), which is a real "Buecherwurm", so far I could despite German translation for none of the books begeistern.Geschmaecker obviously differ. The Winny the witch series has not met our.