Outside "hui" - inside planned obsolescence

Outside "hui" - inside planned obsolescence

Manfrotto Pro Fluid Video Neiger MVH502AH flat base and 504PL (Camera)

Customer Review

For the nominally sophisticated features, the price is very moderate. In this segment, there is no video head with infinitely adjustable friction is (as far as I know) otherwise on both axes. Outside everything is made very solid aluminum and rubber and corresponds to what is also known from the big brother 504HD. About the problems of ergonomics due to the positioning of the brake coil was said elsewhere a lot - I agree in general, but that's not so wild as compared to the actual hit.

If you want to swing very slowly and steadily, you need a high friction. Horizontal works well as it should. However, the soft start of a vertical panning is impossible in the upper third of the friction adjustment due to the underlying construction by 502AH. Turning the friction high, in a play of about one degree, which must be overcome first before the friction intervenes.

The reason is that the outer friction plate is edged with two plastic pins into the metal housing, which are held in position by a respective very strange piece of plastic and a small spring, which is clamped in a recess of the housing. Strange, because this piece of plastic while ensuring that the friction disc normally not flapping around in the cast housing, but the spring with higher torque ultimately gives something to the plastic parts clamp in a different position on the surrounding housing. This reminds not the thoughtful engineering work of the facade, but looks very after a predetermined breaking point. The plastic may hold a number of years, but sitting funnily enough where the largest forces occur (so deep inside that hardly anyone penetrates the tinkering there) and prevents even during normal operation, the expected behavior.
Even as a layman I can think of at least two ways to besetigen this problem: Instead of those weird plastic things screw one or two correspondingly shaped metal disks at this point in the housing to prevent the slipping of the friction disc; use or a version exactly made for friction disc into the case.

That features such as the spring adjustment will not be installed for the purposes of price segmentation or Manfrotto be allowed negligence in ergonomics, is still to be understood. Especially as the other quality for the current market price and, in particular in comparison with its competitors is very high. But that one is fooled with such a concept in gefrickelten Herzststück the Panhead, really can not be.

Who also studied the friction control on both axes and will not slow pan vertically or gets close to it, only to overcome the game and only then to begin the actual swing, and otherwise expect a solid Neiger, thus possibly happy. It is plenty of choice in this price region anyway not.

Addendum of 31/05/2015: The Benro S8 is with 200 euros ex-factory price and exactly this feature is probably a very good competitor.

everything perfect 24 Rank: 5/5
January 19
A real masterpiece! 3 Rank: 5/5
November 4
right product 1269 Rank: 4/5
January 8
Disappointing 1760 Rank: 2/5
November 21

Related Reviews


Outside Hui, inside ... 1Bose ® carrying case for Bose ® IE2 Headphones (Electronics) Outside Hui, inside "ouch my back"XXL Beanbag Black filled with the finest brands EPS beads in premium quality 2-5mm RG 16-18Kg Outside Hui, inside yuck 3mumbi PREMIUM Leather Flip Case Samsung Galaxy S3 / S3 Neo Bag (Accessories) Outside Hui, inside yuck apparently ...Merten 547119 ARGUS smoke detector Basic Longlife polar white (tool) Outside Hui, inside yuck 11Pedea Premium Laptop Case to 39.6 cm (15.6 inches), black (Accessories) Outside Hui, inside ... nothingDome Network Camera IP Camera webcam surveillance Wireless Night Vision IR Wifi Outside Hui, inside yuck but!ERIMA Herren Softshell Tec jacket Activewear (Electronics) Outside Hui inside .... ... well!Music set Horse (Toys) Outside Hui, inside yuck EXTREMEThrustmaster Ferrari Wireless GT Cockpit 430 Scuderia Edition "Born to be the Fastest" PlayStation® 3 (Accessories) Outside Hui inside yuck ---LG 55LA6608 139 cm (55 inches) Cinema 3D LED-backlit TV (Full HD, 400Hz MCI, WLAN, DVB-T / C / S, Smart TV) (Electronics) Outside Hui, inside yuck :( 1Donzo Wallet Structure Case for Nokia Lumia 720 with credit card slots and Stand Function Black (Accessories) Outside hui - inside pfui 2SEA LIFE - Reefmaster DC 1400 HD (Electronics) Outside hui - inside not so hot ...deleyCON 3m HQ Optical Audio Cable - 2x Toslink connector - Optical Digital Fiber Optic Cable - 2.2mm (Electronics) Outside hui - inside pfui 4Chromatic Tuner Digital Tuner Guitar Bass ET68GB Outside Hui, inside yuck ... 5Clatronic MWG 775 H / microwave with grill and convection / 23 liters / stainless steel housing (household goods) Outside Hui, inside ...Falquet & Cie 957B - Ride-Claas Celtis 426RX with trailer (toy) Outside hui - inside a normal toasterSeverin AT 2515 automatic long slot toaster, brushed stainless steel-black / 1000W (household goods) Outside Hui, inside yuck 6Fossil Gents Watch Sport Chronograph CH2565 brown leather (clock) Outside Hui inside yuck 7Karcher HM555 Blenders (incl. Mixing bowl made of glass, 2 speeds, pulse function, modern stainless steel look) (household goods)