Three star deserved .Habe the bulb in my Torchiere (not dimmable) tried this LED. Thanks to the short bulb they do not loomed over the edge. The color was very warm and due to the yellowish Fluterglass. Even in smaller lamps pear due to its size, a good use. 2Stars allowance for the fact that was the pear slight flicker. Maybe it was just a manufacturing defect. Otherwise, this LED has convinced me.