I have long been looking for a bag for my SGS and also tried several. Only now I'm completely satisfied. The phone fits in well, also sits not too tight so that you can easily remove it without using force. I did not so the comments that the phone easily fall before the bungee jumps to machen..kann thing out of the case, do not understand. For normal use, the bag is perfect. The shell is not too bulky, at last I can put it in my pocket. The speaker cutout really makes sense, with some other bags I had vastly adapt so I heard it ring, here this is not the case the volume. I recommend the bag further hesitation.