The mystification of the postures and impostors History

The mystification of the postures and impostors History

A French paradox: anti-racism in the Collaboration, anti-Semitic in the Resistance (Paperback)

Customer Review

This exciting book with plenty sourced, scans the "positioning" of more than 200 personalities from the political, journalistic and intellectual world during the 30s, the war, the occupation and postwar limmédiate.

A first observation: among the personalities of the Vichy regime (Bousquet, Darlan) and collaboration shameless 3rd Reich (Doriot), many will come from the left and who campaigned prewar within the LICA ( future LICRA), or at least expressed loudly against lantisémitisme lentre ... In the wars, although this is the ultra pacifist left that will continue to demand unilateral disarmament of France taking care not to salarmer the massive rearmament of Germany Cest well the House predominantly socialist and radical socialist deputies who gives the constituent powers to Pétain 10 July 1940. Why so many Dreyfusards and danciens philosemites they gravitate around Vichy? Pétain attraction probably Who organizes anti-Jewish raids in 1942 at the request of Laval nest if René Bousquet, radical socialist who sétait already responsible for the repression of nationalist factious leagues in 1936 under the orders of Salengro, Minister of the Interior of popular front

A lopposé, trajectories are equally disconcerting: the 1936 factious (La Rocque), activists and supporters of the action French (Daniel Cordier), denying Maurras at the time of submitting it to Petain, decide dentrer resistance soon the beginning, when few meet the call ... Later still, the trend is confirmed, "in relation to the non-Communist resistance, the weight of originating extreme right is considerable" (Epstein). One of the first clandestine networks, Alliance, founded by Loustaunau-Lacau (right politician dextrême) will claim 3,000 members, among them 300 were shot, hundreds were deported and did not return. These men and women from these nationalists thrive where anti-Jewish prejudice, become resistant and rub shoulders with those that they faced before the war. Some of them will cease BE Semitic, many will remain

However, this book does not just BE umpteenth whos who of resistant and collaborators. Indeed, beyond the singular routes leading to resistance and mass conversions to collaborationism, Simon Epstein demonstrates lextraordinaire imposture of historiography, still in force today, which sévertue to revisit the past to laune good old ideological determinism. Up labsurde "say that collaboration is rooted in fascism of the 30s means that France would have secreted a fascist enslavement dauto putting a point of honor to meet the requirements of the enemy. French fascism was the only one to advocate fascism history leffacement national and collective submission. "(Epstein)

Simon Epstein, the alert pen and irony vacharde samuse usual contortions of these historians and researchers, stuck between the disastrous revelations about the past of each other and their teaching vocations. How falsify by omission the past of a zealous servant of Vichy, when he became President of the Republic wants to use the National Front obscure how these swathes of the parliamentary left and civil society wallowing in collaboration quimporte apologist historian laffirme: wasnt really left the left so short, we must save the "ideological coherence and pathos of the narrative antifascist 1936".

A limmédiate image of post-war, the one that granted amnesty Vichyists (Bousquet) and imprison resistant (Loustaunau-Lacau).

For the price stable tool Rank: 5/5
April 12
Cheap 40 Rank: 3/5
September 22
Zero problems! Rank: 5/5
August 12
Very nice! 202 2 Rank: 4/5
December 28

Related Reviews


Am on the rock And Then i check has stockWall Street and the Rise of Hitler (Paperback) I was disappointed by the characters lack depth, and their history is not transported meUnbreak me: Volume 1 (Paperback) A moving and exciting history, the past Acheron take you to the heart!Dark-Hunter, Book 12: Acheron (Paperback) The route and the personality of the most charismatic pastor of History.Martin Luther King: An intellectual and political biography (Paperback) Entertainment and music history at the same timeMotown Gold (Audio CD) Nick Munro - The man wrote music history and is a living legend!Opera Viva: The century-Concert (Audio CD) Changes the good and less good are ...The Sims 3 (Video Game) NFS - The Run and I'm not over runNeed For Speed: The Run - Limited Edition (Video Game) A series that really come mainly verbally below the belt and at the same time is a successful comedy.Californication - Season 1 (Amazon Instant Video) Hear Riccardo Muti directing "The Sea and Sinbad's boat" ...Rimsky-Korsakov: Scheherazade (CD) Too difficult and too religious: to book for scholars or specialists of the Bible and HebrewThe Female of being: To end the rib of Adam (Paperback) I did not know the authors and I liked.Dent Bear, Volume 1: Max (Album) The incredibly rich universe of Wiedzmin adapted the format and conventions of comics ...The Witcher Volume 1 (Paperback) "From the fun and the emotion"List my desires (Paperback) A vigil air of ancient times, around the fire and no TV.The first (Paperback) The highs and lows of a military genius thoughtThe forgotten Manchuria. Greatness and excessiveness of the art of the Soviet war (Paperback) "I concluded the series, and nothing but write this, tears come to my eyes."Last Sacrifice: A Vampire Academy Novel (Hardcover) beautiful on the substance and formNarcissus and Goldmund (Paperback)