The sound of weight

The sound of weight

Beethoven: Complete Piano Sonatas (Box 12 CD) (CD)

Customer Review

Just over twenty years after the death of the Chilean master, Decca reissued his first complete Beethoven Sonatas; a corpus which, twice under the fingers of Arrau, also has never deserved the title of monumental. (Note that the second capture of 1980-90 will not be complete and there will miss the 14th and 29th sonatas). In addition to luxury, one will find variations of cycles: 15 Eroica Variations op.35, the 32 Variations on an Original Theme, WoO 80, 6 Variations Op. 34, and 33 Diabelli Variations op.120 (captured in 1952).

Recorded between 1962 and 1966, as a prelude to the year of the composer's bicentennial, this integral somehow prefigures the one that will come a quarter century later: an overtly architectural design, an overview prevails throughout to each other, in a cycle that appears to be fully interconnected. A full 32 work like a mythical Hercules whose fulfillment would inevitably superhuman trails (Arrau not he himself said that Beethoven had reached a state of near-cosmic deity?).

As he also said before this Beethoven cycle, "the perfect interpretation would be made in equal parts to the creation of the author and the recreation of the interpreter"; giving the interpreter at work nothing less than blood. The blood arrau, the weight of sound. A perfectly controlled pianism, tamed spontaneously intellectual, authoritarian and severely austerely noble. A speech-based distinction as far as the density on an impeccable rhythmic mastery as well as on perfectly balanced phrasing.

Here, as later, some people sometimes criticize him some slow, see a certain heaviness; but that would confuse apesantissement and weightlessness. For by the majestic gravity qu'Arrau built arches towards the heavenly dimension. One might object that this is sometimes at the cost of light (especially in the sonatas of Youth). However, it is not true that a certain point of view. Because with Arrau Beethoven is as lit from within: in the cathedral he built, the windows are not designed to let in light but to let her out. Under this immanent luminescence, each work takes on a relief uncommon, as revealing a mammoth skeleton.

So obviously, this rigorous and harsh treatment gives great weight to certain sonatas accustomed to a lighter treatment or a short virtuoso outbursts that might seem a little lost here their immediate radiance. It is certainly a bias that may seem confusing, but which keeps a profound coherence: Arrau professes that the genius of Beethoven is present in each measure, and that in these early sonatas are already the close of the last monumental.

In doing so, his Beethoven is less than bows made of bowings: on the shaft of genius Beethoven are not the leaves that are important to him but it is the fruit. Later, Arrau go even further in this direction, and we give a (quasi-) second integral to truly cathédralesques sounds and mystical depth (but at least sometimes insolent technique, more than four times twenty years).

In addition to this edition, some Variations cycles, the premium famous Diabelli 1952. From first almost opposite that it will record at the end of his life, these Diabelli probably more of a surprise, because the game more Quick and brighter than usual seems offer us a virtuoso Arrau more approaching fifty.

It should however not stop at this immediate impression; Arrau's looking good here in real fuel catalyst Beethoven, scoring the architecture and structure in its splendor. Because even the initial Diabelli waltz has already here more nothing trivial: this often any small coin of dresses cornerstone outset of the entire building, the starting point of a cycle to the confusing reading, entirely driven by an irrepressible need. A treatment that thirty years later find a huge re-expression.

Here again available a monumental piano sum obviously essential to any Beethoven disco.

A well-designed flash Rank: 4/5
March 12
As Pro Rank: 5/5
January 31
Excellent 259 50136986 Rank: 4/5
February 24
Useful but cumbersome Rank: 5/5
January 6

Related Reviews


Short Test of BDP-185 and a very important tip for the SoundSony BDP-S185 Blu-ray / DVD player (Internet video) (Electronics) Super materials and processing, the sound you have to but mayAKG K551 Reference Class Over-Ear Headphones with Apple iPhone control and microphone black / silver (Accessories) The sound kitAGPtek An ear in ear Headphones Handsfree Music for Samsung Galaxy S3 S4 S5 Note 2 Iphone 4 4s 5s (Bluetooth 4.0, music streaming, Microphone Mute button, noise cancellation, playback controls, control volume, reduce noise EDR) - Talk / play music until 7:00 - Black (Wireless Phone Accessory) Great design, the sound of small drawbacksDylan ™ COCOON Portable Wireless Bluetooth NFC Speaker with built-in microphone, 10 watt rechargeable speaker system, 1800mAh Li-ion battery, Ultra Bass Booster, Powerful crystal-clear sound, subwoofer effect for iPhone / iPad / Samsung / smart phones and tablets / laptops / ultrabooks / PC computer and other Bluetooth devices (Orange) (Electronics) Very good first impression - especially the sound quality exceeds my expectations!Audio Technica AT-LP120-USBC turntable (Electronics) The sound horribleAEG LBI 4719 Induction Speaker (AUX-IN, 1-piece quantities) (Electronics) The sound system for your pocketCreative Sound Blaster E3 headphone amplifier (3.5mm microphone, Bluetooth, NFC, USB) (Electronics) Sound and weightMeinl Percussion PMDJ1-XL-F plastic Djembe with plastic coat Travel Series Jaw 35.5 cm (14 inches) in diameter (Extra Large) Pharaoh's Script (Electronics) At the end it decides the sound ...JBL Pulse Wireless Bluetooth Speaker with LED function and NFC pairing - Black (Electronics) The sound is good for me that feel more junkSennheiser MX 365 In-Ear Headphones Micro ergonomically Blue (Electronics) I find the sound really good, and I like the great processingMpow® Mbox Portable Wireless Bluetooth 4.0 speakers Ultra bass amplifier, 10 watt speaker system, high-performance Crystal Clear Sound for iPhone 6 6 PLUS 5S 5C 5 4S, iPad 4 3 2, iPad Mini Air, Samsung Galaxy S5 S4 S3, Galaxy Tab Laptops and PC computer MP3 player, etc. (Black) (Electronics) Optics and service are very good, but the sound ...Loewe Speaker2go 2.1 Portable speakers (40 watts, USB) Silver (Electronics) The sound quality is OK, but not comfortable.Philips SHE7005A / 00 Android in-ear headphones, speakerphones black (Accessories) The small box is the sound forth a giant ...RAIKKO® POCKET BEAT 3.0 Bluetooth ® speakers, stereo, robust aluminum housing (2x 3 Watt, microUSB, Line-IN) - black - (Electronics) Not only the price / performance ratio, but also the sound of the blast: Sony STR-DN1050Sony STR-DN1050 7.2 Channel Receiver (4K upscaling, 3D, 6x HDMI IN, 2x HDMI OUT, GUI, Wireless LAN, Bluetooth, NFC, AirPlay, DLNA, Internet Radio, Spotify) (Electronics) The headphones can be surprisingly comfortable and ergonomic wearing the head - the sound quality is okay.Mpow® Cheetah Bluetooth 4.1 Wireless Sweat Catcher Sport Headphones with Microphone APTX technology and the handsfree function for iPhone 6 6 PLUS 5S 5C 5 4S iPad, Samsung Galaxy S4 S3 Note 3 and other mobile phone (electronic) Good Soundbar, the sound not our tasteSony HTCT370 2.1 channel sound bar (300 watts, bass reflex speaker, Wireless Subwoofer, NFC, Bluetooth, virtual surround sound) (Electronics) Very convenient. The sound is very good without an area to emphasize particularlyAudio Technica ATH-MSR7 High Resolution headphones Silver (Electronics) The sound is an unnecessary but critical flawPhilips 24PFL3507H / 12 61 cm (24 inch) LED backlight TVs (Full HD, DVB-T / C, CI +, Smart TV (Youtube and DLNA)) (Electronics)