This defective Blu-ray Disc simply worthless!

This defective Blu-ray Disc simply worthless!

Wish You Were Here Immersion Box (2 CDs, 2 DVDs, 1 Blu-ray) (Audio CD)

Customer Review

Even on my copy of the Blu-ray Disc are the 5.1 surround mix at the end of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Part 9", more precisely at minute 43:55 and 44:10 clearly two clicks on the left front channel hear , At first I thought yes, just my Blu-ray had broken down, but now five more buyers are known to me, complaining about the exact same error. For safety, I heard even the 5.1 surround mix of "audio only" DVD (of course, not to be confused with a lossless DVD audio) on. Although called track works properly, but this sounds compressed audio format (448 or 640 kbps) just awful compared to the high resolution Blu-ray Disc.

After my experience with the delivered in September "Dark Side Of The Moon" immersion box is no longer surprised, unfortunately, that this time all the discs loosely in the box flew about and are significantly scratched part. The holder of the discs in the box is basically already thought through; also hold the pieces of silver, if they are pressed accordingly. Only you would be aware that they will be solved during transport out of the holder. It would be better therefore been, it easy to pack in protectors and example. To lay on top, because the unprotected insert the Blu-ray in a Cardboard Sleeve protects the surfaces of the disc is not really!

I want to leave no detail at this point about the value for money of the box, after all I already knew since its announcement that I would have basically only used for Disc 2 and the Blu-ray. The previously unreleased audio tracks on Disc 2 but convince me sound technically and very especially in front of their historical background. Without located exclusively on the Blu-ray Disc 4.0 quad mix with different track lengths, different melody lines, guitar solos, new and altered Background arrangements and alternative synth tracks I would have loved to just the Experience Edition and on the real audiophile "Analogue Productions" buy label appearing SACD of "Wish You Were Here", is but also in the other Immersion Box additions (like marbles and scarf) to unnecessary frills.

That there is very different, the 40th Anniversary Box Set proves Jethro Tull of "Aqualung": Valuable box, hard cover book, ingenious arrangement of the discs in gatefold cover, high quality Blu-ray Disc with all stereo, Quadraphonic-, surround versions and bonus tracks in Lossless format and as a blockbuster that also audiophile 180 gram vinyl. The crowning glory is the 5.1 surround mix by Steven Wilson, who just as well I like how his genius Surround mixes eg. For Porcupine Tree and King Crimson. He's just a gifted musician, and so it would have been very interested in what he had taken out of "Wish You Were Here" or other timeless Floyd works ...

Addendum:

After I received yesterday a further (second) WYWH Immersion Box of Amazon.com, the on top lying Blu-ray was once the way to my new Cambridge Azur 751BD. Unfortunately, confirmed my fears - it has the 5.1 surround track the exact same error. After my phone conversation today with Amazon.com was agreed that I would return both copies of the immersion box. The very friendly Amazon customer service informed me upstairs talk also about the fact that the box will temporarily taken out of the product range.

Today (10:11.) Now regrets EMI Music Germany that I have purchased a defective product out of her house and asks me to send in the defective Blu-ray. The friendly email ends with the following announcement: "Once we have is a perfect version available, we will immediately send a copy of it."

In light of these recent developments, I reserve a copy of the box and look forward to the timely possible replacement.

Very good against dry scalp Rank: 5/5
November 4
Okay January 2299 Rank: 5/5
May 27
Less than the original one Rank: 1/5
July 4

Related Reviews


Review Philips HTB9225D 2.1 sound system with 3D Blu-ray Disc PlayerPhilips Fidelio HTB9225D / 12 2.1 home theater system with Crystal Clear Sound (3D Blu-ray; Smart TV Plus; 500W; titanium tweeter; HDMI; Bluetooth; ActiveSubARC; Ipod WiFi) Black / Silver (Electronics) BUROSCH Expert TV and Beamer Tuning Blu-ray DiscBUROSCH EXPERT TV TUNING Blu-ray Disc (Blu-ray) MediaRange MR507 BD-R DL 6x Blu-ray Disc 50GByte (10 pieces)MediaRange MR507 BD-R DL 6x Blu-ray Disc 50GByte (10 pieces) (Accessories) Class burner! In particular, for the M-Disc DVD and Blu-ray Disc-M!Buffalo BRXL-16U3-EU external Blu-ray burner 16x USB 3.0 with CyberLink Software Suite (optional) Verbatim Blu-ray Disc high quality !!Verbatim VBR260YP50V1 read / write blu-ray disc (BD) (Personal Computers) Super Blu Ray disc player at a fair priceSony BDP S 360 Blu Ray Player (1080p Full HD, Deep Color, Dolby True HD, DTS HD) (Electronics) Light mobile solid laptop with Blu-ray Disc and HSUPA moduleSony Vaio SB1Z9E / B 33.8 cm (13.3-inch) notebook (Intel Core i5 2410M 2.3GHz, 6GB RAM, 500GB HDD, AMD HD 6470M, Blu ray, Win 7 Pro) Black (Personal Computers) Play Blu-ray discs easily and in very good qualityPowerDVD 13 Pro (CD-ROM) Blu-ray Disc MediaRange BD-R 25 GB, 1-4x Speed ​​in Cakebox 50 piecesBlu-ray Disc MediaRange BD-R 25 GB, 1-4x Speed ​​in Cakebox 50 piece (electronics) Could be almost the perfect Blu-ray player. Had .. almost ..Philips BDP7700 / 12 3D Blu-ray player with Full HD (Smart TV Plus, WiFi, 7.1 surround sound), Black (Electronics) Very bad authoring the DVD and Blu-Ray, probably to obtain a higher price for the purpose,Depeche Mode Live in Berlin (Audio CD) For Blu Ray, DVD, Internet, music, pictures = YES ----- For games (r) = NOPlayStation 3 remote control, black (Accessories) Multimedia Blu-ray recorder of the highest class - Operating unhelpfulPanasonic DMR-BST730EG Blu-ray Recorder with Twin HD (DVB-S tuner, Full HD, 6x speed, BD-R DL, 500GB hard drive, 2x CI +) (Electronics) My first Blu-ray player for less moneySony BDP-S480 3D Blu-ray Player (USB, HDMI, 1080p upscaling, WiFi ready) (Electronics) Very good Blu-ray / SACD / DVD / CD player!Sony BDP-S490 3D Blu-ray Player (2D / 3D, HDMI, 1080p upscaler, iPhone / Android-controllable DLNA) (Electronics) Just see only Blu-ray ....Philips BDP3300 / 12 Blu-ray Disc / DVD player (DivX Plus HD WiFi-ready, USB 2.0) Black (Personal Computers) Blu-Ray burner ideal for back-up and burningAsus BW-12D1S-U external Blu-Ray burner (12x BD-R, 16x DVD ± R, 8x DVD ± R DL, 5x DVD-RAM, USB 3.0) incl. Cyberlink PowerDVD 10 3D & Power2Go, Black (Accessories) The latest recorders-readers LG 3D Blu-ray M-disk that does everything (or almost).LG BP40NB30 Burner USB 2.0 external Blu-Ray BD-R 6x, DVD + R / W 8x, 6x DVD +/- R Black (Accessory)