As Hal Willner absolute fan I bought these double CD. To me she likes unfortunately not as good as the rest, for example: the tributes to Kurt Weill, Disney or Thelonius Monk. Even the predecessor "Rogues Gallery" I find better. The would get me 4 to 5 stars In my opinion, the songs seem to be not as good as that in the first part. Since there are, for example: my son John, hanging Jonny, rolling sea and many more.
My highlights are here: Shenandoah with Tom Waits and the wedding dress song by Zappa and the Mothers of Invention.
If something should change in repeated listening, I write yet.