I had always baskets that are moored with a clamping device on the carrier, and practical, but this type baskets held only nine months because then corroded the tensioning device and fell apart. Here the mounting is much simpler, yet rock solid, I see no slipping or rattling. A small drawback is that you can already after 4 weeks on the handle and rim provides a couple of small paint damage and also the brand label has been peeled. So I will not ever even accompany this basket, but longer than the others, I'm guessing because the attachment is not affected, and easier to use it is. In addition, we now also has the Porter-free and can it stall even luggage there.