I was referring mainly to the protection of the iPhone4S. The bag looks very valuable from, served its purpose very well, the protection of the phone is very good. The removal of the iPhone from the Platikrahmen is very difficult, but it keeps but so much the better. To charge is thankfully no removal necessary, as it has a corresponding bulge. Only as written here several times the small tab of the cover opens and the magnet is liable to be lost. Based on the reviews of others I knew it beforehand and could keep an eye on. I noticed it in time and have it closed again with superglue. Now it seems to hold.
Had I lost the magnets, it would have been no 5 star, but it's so worth it the maximum score well.