The bottom:
The problem is that a neophyte who would choose good whiskeys to be a cellar is not at all helped by this book.
Indeed they are not listing the many appreciations fruits and vegetables that will help her choose whiskeys.
For this book to be useful for a beginner, it would have had to include for each whiskie:
- The price range of whiskie, 4 or 5 slices enough price
- A note in the absolute quality
- A note in value
- A short list of whiskeys like (I know I love this whiskie, so I should also like them)
and end of the book a ranking of 10 or top 20 for each price range.
Thus the neophyte could easily be its cellar whiskeys, which is not at all the case with this book.