A sequel, yes, but ...

A sequel, yes, but ...

Scarlett (Paperback)

Customer Review

For an unconditional Gone With The Wind, the film and the book best seller in its time of Margaret Mitchell, difficult not to read THE result of this legendary saga, especially when one has never resolved its end Scarlett and Rhett, it's over.

So after he got there (mostly because of financial interests: the heirs want to keep copyright ...), even TV movie adapted in the 90: adapting itself very free and very mushy Book Scarlett by Alexandra Ripley, who do not really do it justice.

Scarlett is a dense book, whose action is between America and Ireland. It follows the adventures of heroin between the two continents, we watch every game with the same furtive Rhett. As for the end, for you to discover ...

Although this result certainly delight fans of Scarlett, the book (which I reread many times since my teens) may appear sometimes disappointing, because in my opinion it lacks credibility.

True, the author weaves the action on a historical background (here, Ireland). But the Ripley's Scarlett is not, for me, the same as that of Mitchell more softened, more sedate and less plague, manipulative and bounded, in brief a friendly word. We can say that she has matured, but if all the details of the characters are in agreement with Mitchell's novel, I find it somewhat unfortunate that makes Ripley Scarlett character too mushy.
Let us remember Scarlett: physical pleasure was not really his cup of tea. That is even why she did "reserved" to her husbands, not by morality of the time. And then, like magic, it turns to the torrid affair (with Rhett, or other ...).
Finally, placing the action out of America, Ripley prevents its main character does cotoie too often the others, those who were in Mitchell's novel: as if the author could not be doing together, to make them credible.

To read, certainly if we liked the book Michell and if you want a reply to an end !!!

A bag, no more, no less Rank: 5/5
May 16
Good, but not with Windows Rank: 2/5
December 1
j'adooore 2 Rank: 5/5
November 18
olivier 1 Rank: 5/5
April 13

Related Reviews


Two * jein *, a * yes but *, a * more * No * Yes * and a clear promise to the 5 for this 5-in-1 wonder cream.BB Cream 5-in-1 medium to dark, 1er Pack (1 x 50 ml) (Health and Beauty) Yes, but ... 27Autoled 0050 2 P21W Bulb Daytime Running Light (18 tablets SMD5050) Lighting BAU15S - White (Automotive) Yes, but 50Travel Blue Ticket hide Belt Black / Ivory (Sport) Yes, but ... 88Fraulein38 lot 12 makeup brushes eye shadow kit gray leopard (Miscellaneous) Yes, but not with Windows 8 ...Toshiba Satellite C875D-107 Notebook 17.3 '' (43.94 cm) AMD E series 500 GB RAM, 5400 MB AMD Radeon HD 7310M Windows 8 White (Personal Computers) Beautiful screen ... yes but only on paper!Asus RoG Swift PG278Q PC screen TN LED 27 "(69 cm), 2560x1440, 1 sc, active 3D (Nvidia 3D Vision 2), DisplayPort / USB 3.0 Hub (Accessory) a box for your key, yes but ....Remote key shell case plip key car Peugeot 107 207 307 Bialetti yes but not villainous sellersBialetti Venus 4 11B1682 Coffee Mugs (Kitchen) Yes, but 246The one I'm not: Volume 1 (Album) Yes, but! 271NF-S12A FLX (Accessory) Protection yes, but nothing moreOtterBox Commuter Series Cases for HTC One M8 black (Accessories) Great graphics hats yes, but ne Economic / building simulation without economic cycle?Grand Ages: Rome (computer game) Schick and robust YES, but unfortunately very slowKingston DataTraveler DTSE9H 32GB flash drive USB 2.0 Silver (accessory) Yes but ...Chio Popcorn sweet, 11er Pack (11 x 100 g) (Misc.) Wireless yes, but for what?Fujitsu ScanSnap scanner iX500 (600dpi, WLAN, USB 3.0) (Accessories) Yes, but ... 46The last colony (Paperback) yes but ... 78Smoby - 434,110 - Tricycle - Baby Driver Comfort Paris (Toy) Yes, but not 9Desigual Twist Everyday Bag, Women Handbag (Clothing) Yes, but that is ....APC UPS Back UPS 650VA / 400 Watts, 4 IEC outlets (Electronics)