When rear fender I was not completely satisfied because it sticks in the back of a long way out by its length and is again very close to the tires. Since I have a porter, hit the rear part of the big game also still on the luggage rack on. With a small hole and a cable tie on the other hand I could quickly eliminate the somewhat rickety affair. Without Porter I can well imagine that there can be a frequent contact with the tires here also.
The product comes by the way of a German company, which has me somewhat by surprise. My order from Amazon Read the other hand a lot of time, because the supply came from Spain. Whether that is so or always Amazon just like superimposed fenders in Spain, I can not judge because I rarely buy mudguards for bicycles ;-)