I find the atmosphere unbeatable and soon better than in the other parts of Silent Hill (Did all played). The story is great, the end also great. Sometimes, however, the logic remains somewhat on the track. And a couple of messages somehow do not fit the story I think. The one does not necessarily have to fight, I find not bad, but it is cumbersome ever to escape, so that part is to save the manufacturers quietly. Nevertheless, I think the game has succeeded because of the aforementioned drawbacks but only 4 stars. Nevertheless it should have every Silent Hill fan played once.