Meinereiner for over 20 years now plays on consoles and the computer. Started G7000 Philips. I have at this time a large number of controllers in the hand and had to 360 was the Sidewinder pad as the best thing that came out so far. But the 360 pad makes virtually everything right. It fits comfortably in your hand, it has the right weight (not so fiddly easy as PS Pad), good arrangement of the buttons and sticks shoulder buttons.
Only what must be able to hold against MS that the controllers are not shipped with a battery, but that you have to buy more this again.
Let's hope the MS takes the controller to the next generation.