Consider buying twice!

Consider buying twice!

Proxima Direct USB to Midi Cable Keyboard for PC Laptop Adapter - For Win 7, XP Vista Mac Plug and Play

Customer Review

I am a little surprised about the many positive reviews. Out-of-the-box was not working this adapter with me namely! What, as it turned out to not happened by chance. The adapter was recognized by Windows 8 correctly as a USB MIDI adapter and the appropriate drivers are also installed automatically, but could not receive signals from the computer connected via the adapter MIDI devices. The indicator light for Midi In and Midi Out nor twitched. (The functionality of MIDI devices you can check the way with the freeware tool MIDIOX.)

After I opened the adapter (which is available under identical tens different brand names to buy here at Amazon), I saw that the components on the board were missing and the DIN connector were soldered somehow strange. The soldering made, at least in the labeling of the solder points on the board to, no sense to me.

I then googled and came across the part of Mr. Arvydas UK (arvydas.co.uk) encountered on the technical problems of this adapter (Arvydas board saw hair exactly like mine!) Had been described and solved. So I was not the only one, in which the adapter was not working. Since I do not directly on Arvydas page can link here, you must ergoogeln even the page. Here the necessary keywords: "Arvydas cheap USB MIDI cable some self assembly may be required".

Arvydas problem analysis:

The adapter does not correspond to the MIDI standard (to the find by "Electrical Specification for MIDI - MIDI Manufacturers Association" googling!): On the board is missing an optocoupler and a switching diode. The DIN connectors are also not soldered according to the MIDI standard.

Necessary components:

- 1 1-channel optocoupler with 4 pins (. I have a PC817 SOP-4 used for 15 pieces I paid 2 euros on eBay Arvydas used a SFH618-2 DIP-4..)
- 1220 ohm resistor

Non-essential components:

- 1 switching diode 1N4148 or 1N914

The solution (along the instructions of Arvydas with two small additions of me to meet the Midi standard course, all this is no guarantee.):

- Optocoupler to the corresponding point of the solder board U1 - correctly orientated!
- Remove On the board the bridge resistor R11. (Between the two solder points may then there are no longer any connection!)
- A 220 ohm resistor at R5 solder. (A normal resistance should fit easily with a bit of good will)
- The lack of diode D1 can one save. (But who really wants, like me, who must a common 1N4148 or 1N914 diode switching here according to MIDI standard - note orientation - soldering the adapter works well without..)
- If necessary, re-solder the wires of the DIN connector with the board. The result should look like this:
Midi-Out:
- White or green on D + (per DIN connector there are three wires Said wire is either white or green.!)
- Black on D-
- Does not connect red (or according to MIDI standard with G / GND on the board)
Midi-In:
- White or green on IN + (This strand was cut with me from work and had to be extended!)
- Black on IN-
- Red not connect (Really!))
- Adapter with MIDI devices and computer connect and test (with MIDIOX). He should now work and the control lights on the board should all go. Otherwise, debugging is a must!
- If the adapter is working, cover it and find that the four nipples that are held together both plastic lid are all aborted when opened. So both covers with a few windings tape sticking together professionally. Done.

My adapter is working properly since.

All in all, these USB Midi adapter a pretty little electric project. But let's be honest, who has just expects a factory working USB MIDI adapter and professionally even a hobby to do with electronics either, for this adapter would be definitely a bad buy.

Related Reviews


Who buys cheap, buys twice! 2Xbox360 Play & Charge Battery Controller Charging Cable Black (Video Game) Who 'cheap' buys, buys twice! 35 cartridges compatible for HP 364 XL 364XL Set with chip and level (Office supplies & stationery) ... Who buy cheap, buy twiceHQ Audio extension cable (jack plug to jack clutch) 10 m (optional) UNBEATABLE VALUE FOR MONEY !! SUPER PRODUCT THAT MAKES ME CONSIDER BUYING SECOND ...DURAGADGET Car Holder Multifunction 3 in 1 (Air Vent Holder, Windscreen and Dashboard) Phone / Smartphone Samsung Galaxy Note 2 / II N7100 Note Car Charger + BONUS - 5 year warranty (Electronics) Who buys approves, buys twiceOriginal smartec24® iPhone 4 4S Schaub Overcoat black screwdriver 5 Star Pentalobe Torx Scout tool (electronics) Who buys billg, buys twiceUniversal projector mount in White | Aluminium ceiling mount projector projector mount | mounting bracket projector ceiling mount bracket assembly | pivotally rotated 360 degrees | up to 10kg (electronics) Total leaking - "Whoever buys cheap buys twice!"Tomy Aquadoodle pin Two Pack [DVD] (Toys) "Buy cheap, buy twice!"LI-ION BATTERY for Canon PowerShot G12, PowerShot SX30 IS replaces original battery NB-7L (Electronics) Who buys this cheap, buys twice!Durable 822,901 Jojo Plus, band length 60 cm, black, 10 per pack (Office supplies & stationery) Consider buying several shades!Letraset pocket markers (markers sold separately) (Others) We still consider buying ablue Prepaid SIM card including 10 Euro credit, 9 cents per minute / SMS dt in all. networks, 25 euros for Mobile Numbers Portability (Accessories) Unfortunately, you always buys twicePanasonic ER-1611 professional hair clipper (Personal Care) A "MG" - sometimes you go - device. Unfortunately cheap buy twiceNetgear GS208-100PES Gigabit Switch (8-port) (Accessories) Who buys cheap, buys twice!Calvin Klein Eternity for Men homme / men, Eau de Toilette, Vaporisateur / Spray, 100 ml (Personal Care) Who buys cheap, buys twice. 3Saeco HD8762 / 01 Minuto coffee machine, automatic milk frother, Black (Kitchen) Who buys cheap, buys twice. 1 2Adaptare stereo gold-plated 3.5mm jack cable 1m (accessory) Who buys cheap, buys twice (incl. Alternative proposal)Nokia Lumia 530 Smartphone incl. Cover (10.2 cm (4 inches), dual SIM, 1.2GHz Snapdragon quad-core processor, 512MB RAM, 5 megapixel camera, Bluetooth, USB 2.0, Win 8) White (Electronics) Who buys cheap, buys twice! 7Sanifri 470010700 Hand shower "Unit I" 70 mm, chrome (tool) True to the adage: Who buys cheap, buys twice ...PlayStation 3 - Konsole Slim Super 12 GB (incl. DualShock 3 Wireless Controller) (console)