I've used this lotion specially one week every day and so far everything is ok. The eyes are thoroughly abgeschminkt and I do not react with redness or itching on the skin around the eyes while spanning a little more than usual, but that goes by when I put some cream. If I apply even really thick, this lotion has to fight something. Then it's not so easy off I've got my eyes but so heavily made only for the test, for my normal make-up it is sufficient.
Conclusion: I forgive four stars because my eyes are well and thoroughly abgeschminkt. The fifth star I keep because the skin a little bit more tensioned around my eyes than usual, and I would apply this lotion on my skin not daily. For waterproof mascara I find it ideal.