It's strange because this saga parrait be the twilight of roughing and, suddenly, twilight the finished product. It starts sympatiquement and then I think the soufflé does not. To my taste, the author gives us no attachment to the characters, to their emotions, to their love stories ... Too bad, too bad ... for a little more depth would not have hurt. Is readable but, but ... is not stephanie meyer wants, and thus refrain twilight fan!