Extensive but somewhat superficial

Extensive but somewhat superficial

Genesis Anthology (Paperback)

Customer Review

As a longtime fan and connoisseur of all Genesis albums, I have long been waiting for such an extensive collection of Genesis-grade material. From the Genesis Songbooks previously available I was always quite disappointed, because for my taste, most of the really beautiful musical ideas of the songs (eg riffs, original Klaviervoicings, ...) were not carefully notated in the score enough. That's why I was more pleased that now, this Anthology Hal Leonard offers, so one of the world's leading central publishers with high quality standards at such an affordable price!

All hits of pop era are content naturally represented by Genesis, but beyond that also many songs that you have not so often get in the form of notes to face, such as more complex pieces like "Robbery, Assault And Battery" or "One For The Vine ".

Unfortunately, I realized quickly that the quality of the piano reductions in many cases not much successful than the previous Songbooks. Particularly annoying I find that just the interesting instrumental passages longer compositions were often left out simply, so as the grandiose keyboard solo from "Fading Lights" (which only makes it worth listening to, in my opinion the song). Also missing wide passages in "Cinema Show", "Robbery, Assault And Battery", "Firth Of Fifth" uva - incomprehensible in my eyes, because, for example, the long and sometimes equally complex keyboard solos of "Second Home By The Sea" and "In The Cage" are notated exemplary.

Praiseworthy are some very successful piano arrangements mentioned, which can already played at sight pay the typical Genesis flair, such as "Heathaze" and "Man On The Corner".

Overall, this Anthology leaves so a streaky impression: 40-50% of the pieces are very good arranged for piano, the rest just as much as possible. You can tell that someone has made an effort. Unfortunately, there are many arrangements that are then this does not do justice to quality and you have the impression that the arrangers ran out of patience and care here ...

It should nevertheless be all those who simply want time for little money have a truly comprehensive collection of Genesis notes, this songbook is strongly recommended, because despite these criticisms are the arrangements for the "Otto-Normal-keyboardist" more than useful!

Very disappointing 14 1 Rank: 1/5
September 11
Very useful 129 Rank: 3/5
December 22
Perfect 1 5444 Rank: 4/5
August 22
Silicone Case 1 4 Rank: 3/5
December 7
Very satisfied by the chair Chicco Rank: 5/5
December 15

Related Reviews


A good thought but somewhat disjointed scriptResident Evil: Revelations (Video Game) very extensive, but not always easy to useCorel Paint Shop Pro X6 Ultimate (CD-ROM) Solid and good - but somewhat predictableRave Head (LTD. Digipak + DVD) (Audio CD) Convenient, but somewhat unstableWenko 6200060100 wardrobe system Apollon (household goods) Quiet and fast, but somewhat complicated setupCanon PIXMA MG3550 multifunction (printer, copier, scanner, USB, WLAN) Black (Personal Computers) Long lasting, but somewhat hardOral-B Ortho OD17 brush - 5 piece (Personal Care) Good deal for the fans but somewhat disappointingThe Sims 4 - Collector's Edition (computer game) Good extension / USB 2.0 extension BUT ...Belkin USB 2.0 AB Extension AA M / F 1 m (Accessory) Good light, but somewhat shaky assemblyInstallation 5W - 400 lumens - LED lamp Recessed Spotlights 230V as a complete set, frame Stainless steel chrome-colored, (brushed) great looks, but somewhat unstableScotch tape dispenser CATSM4 Promotion in cat form, including 4 wheels Magic Tape, 19 mm x 33 m, white (Office supplies & stationery) Varied, extensive but difficultStuntman: Ignition (video game) image absolutely wonderful and sound clear but somewhat quiet when walking my Dyon android box of hdmi to avGeneric Mini HDMI RCA 2 AV converter for TV VCR VCR DVD (electronic) Good disc, but somewhat one-sidedWay of the Fist (Audio CD) Very extensive, but not so easy to use as suggestedXara Web Designer 10 (DVD-ROM) Great Folie- attachment but somewhat problematic because of the rounded edgesArktisPRO iPad Air Premium protector back (electronic) nice and long - but somewhat impracticalABUS folding lock Bordo Big 6000/120 (equipment) Extensive, but not complete collectionMythology (MP3 Download) Very neat, but somewhat fimschig in useFoton F-ring focus ring FRG13 (focus lever for DSLR or camcorder, diameter 76-80mm) (Electronics) Practical extension, but ...Leatherman bit holder extension (tool)