For a medieval renaissance.

For a medieval renaissance.

The Middle Ages, a sham (Paperback)

Customer Review

In this book Jacques Heers (a name predestined for a medievalist historian!) Up to the plate to dispel the vision of a Middle Ages violent, obscurantist, symbolized by an artistic regression (Gothic barbarism opposed to the purity of the ancient art) and a demeaning feudalism.

In the first part, it criticizes at length the concept of "Renaissance" historical epoch "invented" by the later periods (the Enlightenment, Revolution, republic), the better to castigate the Middle Ages and justify the "benefits" of modernism.

A sledgehammer blows of arguments, the author catapult off all the clichés, platitudes or cartoons about the medieval period (which are too often encountered in the history books, film or some literature).

On the merits, it is smoothly conducted. It is rather about the form that the fishing book reading is sometimes difficult even arid, and the text lacks picturesque anecdotes. If we really do not mind, we have to do a little violence because it is often difficult to read a chapter of a trait.

I also find that the author focuses on the supposed end of the Middle Ages (XIV and XV century) and the whole period from the end (always assumed) of the Roman Empire in the year one thousand (including terror would have never existed) is well covered. Jacques Heers is also very hard on the ins historians and writers of the "old Middle Age", it tends to repeat his charges too and get a little too forward.

Almost perfect 35 Rank: 4/5
November 16
Best Release title! Rank: 5/5
December 11
As another guest who commented Rank: 1/5
August 7
Pretty little story. Rank: 3/5
February 9
Necessary book. Rank: 3/5
April 12

Related Reviews


for me the most beautiful CDShadow of the Moon (Audio CD) Super shoe for a reasonable priceVelvet Ballerina CHINA FLAT darkred (Shoes) Medieval Blouse ecruMiddle Ages - Medieval Blouse - Ecru (Toy) For child's birthdayKNIGHT SET Party Decoration Knight Party (Toy) super quality 18Clothing / Medieval / mercenary / robe / black-brown, XL (Textiles) sweet samtballerinasVelvet Ballerina CHINA FLAT midnight blue (Shoes) A beautiful and enchanting bookThe Great Encyclopedia Wonderful NE (Hardcover) An interesting story 1Billions of hair mats (Paperback) Something different than pabulum.Divinity II: Ego Draconis (computer game) Book with a differenceNeutral Guestbook made of wood sheet 100 | 200 pages A classic game with a new lookBridge Constructor Middle Ages (computer game) Super METViking Gift Set - 1x 0.5L Red Viking mead with cherry flavor + 1x 0.5L Original Viking mead each Viking blood + 2 tone mug (Wine) Product, shipping, contact properly.Decowa Necklace Howling Wolf (jewelry) great value for money, the dress will be attracted to each Medieval Festival and looks great ....Pink Girls Princess Costume Age 3 (Toys) Shoes for medieval outfitFuntasma Medieval boots for men: Renaissance 50 (textiles) Medieval music in easier and more enjoyable way for the earsPour l'amour (love songs of the 14th and 15th century) (Audio CD) Good book for understanding the early Renaissance1515 - The invention of the Renaissance (Paperback) Medieval Tycoon!The big Heart (Paperback)