We draw our puppies on with MeraDog lining and so I came to this treat. They are nice and small and taste obviously good. From the composition of the positive side for me that they have a fairly low protein and fat have (12.5% and 6.5%) and so do not go too much on the young hips. The dry treats left no grease stains and the hands are not greasy. Disadvantage is that a puppy has a few seconds needed to chew the small bone and thus is not as well suited for intensive training. Since I take rather then back on soft and fast eaten treats. Overall, I am very happy and my dog too :)