I give the sleeve 5 stars for the reason that fulfills its purpose the shell. Only, it is unfortunately a fake by another original envelope. The first Beweiß is says on the box "Made in China". I'm going to write in to you the full name of good original piece (it is on Amazon) "Spigen Galaxy S5 Case Tough Armor Series Gunmetal SGP10762" I hope I could help you further. PS: I have this bought later my shell and it is amazing! I can recommend only the other sleeve!