Similar to the review on the Ishild Leather Case for Iphone's situation is the product here. In the beginning the impression is good, keeps shutter and the device is securely in its holder. But even here the Galaxy resolves after some involuntary falls from the inner bracket and slams defenseless gene floor. The magnetic closure keeps initially quite good, wears out after a short time but sometimes "breaks" from the leather. Thus, this model was after 2 months replaced by a more expensive product with a partial magnetic closure.