Not quite sure of the value of the object ....

Not quite sure of the value of the object ....

OMRON HEM-6150-E Blood Pressure Wrist MIT Accuracy 5 (Health and Beauty)

Customer Review

Other than me (starting with Amazon, so by the manufacturer) have already made the product descriptions in detail much better than I can do it, so I will spare you the description.

But it turns out that I am a general practitioner, and that it has been almost thirty years since I use blood pressure monitors dozens of times each day. We are very far here from the good old sphygmomanometer (cuff that inflates with small hand pump with a needle dial ...) with the monitor listening for the brachial artery (neck), but the principle remains the same: a small pump, electrical this time, a cushion that inflates thereby tightens the wrist slightly, and a sensor (acoustic or pressure?) that measure the flow of blood through the radial artery and the brachial not . It does not change, in theory, not much to the measured pressures.

I compared with fifteen volunteers with taking traditional measure, using both methods in succession on the same arm / wrist, the traditional method (manual) first or second chance. Whenever I found a difference generally pretty minimal (sometimes quite large at first, it was enough to start the two measures move closer to see, probably eliminating the emotional factor). We can therefore deduce that the measure is probably pretty reliable.

I also compared with other electronic sphygmomanometer, cuff one, and, curiously, the differences were much larger, not the pressure of numbers (or voltage), but the heart rate measurement. So unreliable that point of view, the measure to the former (the pulse with a watch over 30 seconds or 1 minute) being the reference.

I finally used the device in two patients with true full arrhythmia (atrial fibrillation by for connoisseurs, and anticoagulants) and knew the power numbers seemed correct to me (which is harder to see when the rhythm is not regular, even in the ear), the unit did not detect the arrhythmia as yet it is supposed to.

Okay, now, the interest of the thing, I really doubt if your blood pressure is too high at the start, and requires treatment, this type of device is useless compared to medical follow you need (medical, NOT to the chemist where TA is almost never taken in good conditions). And if your blood pressure is usually normal, it is no use at all. As a bonus, if your blood pressure is doubtful ie between the two, you'll get it up every time you take the unit by the stress of the measure.

So rather just pretend device for blood pressure, unreliable for heart rhythm without true medical interest. No doubt a proper construction, but I find, super expensive. Especially for the interest it has ...

good quality for price 153 Rank: 4/5
September 26
unconverted 1 test Rank: 2/5
February 22
Good but 308 Rank: 3/5
May 5
Almost perfect 196 Rank: 4/5
January 29
Answer 6 Rank: 5/5
August 21

Related Reviews


Good but not quite inexpensive - about the benefits one can argue, depends on the water quality plan onPetra Electric ACF 4 antichlor filter (household goods) Good quality but does not quite exactly like the photoOriginal Akira Handmade genuine leather Samsung Galaxy S6 Flip Limited Edition Wallet Cover Handmade Case Cover Case Flip Wallet Pen cowhide dark brown (Electronics) Not quite ready for the manufacturer's customer service miesSamsung - WB710 (Black) - Camera (Electronics) Thought not quite up to the endRosenstein & Söhne glass kettle with display and temperature selection Unfortunately copywriting is not quite right with the actual circumstances - Handling I have not yet been testedMantona Azurite Photo Backpack for SLR Camera (Accessories) Poor quality + dmension not quite compatible with the nexus4Accessory Master Black Book style leather case shell case for Lg Nexus 4 E960 (Accessory) Not quite fit with the German gas cylinders - but nice opticsWeber 3973 Gas bottles protective cover 5 kg (garden products) Very good performance, but does not quite serve up the originalBattery for Nikon EN-EL14 ENEL14 1030mah / P7100 P7000 (P7700 to Update 1.2) D5100 D5200 D3200 D3100 with newest info chip (electronic) Not quite thought through the curls.Philips HP8634 / 00 ProCare styling brush, retractable bristles, violet (Personal Care) Great voice, not quite convinced of the choice of the genreI Stand (Audio CD) Not quite like in the product descriptionGERMAS Halswärmer Taslan (with zip), Gr. XL (Automotive) Good idea, unfortunately, thought not quite up to the endAllocacoc P-CUBE-EXT Powercube Extended Power Extension (5x distribution, 230V power) Boston red (tool) Not quite what promises the image.Plasma ball 30cm - Plasma radiation Centered (Electronics) Not quite conform to the product soldRapidNFC NTAG203 29mm transparent NFC Tags pack of 10 (Electronics) Efficient but not quite suited to the phone6 x Membrane screen protection films Nokia Lumia 520 - Clear Ultra Packaging (Electronics) Not quite complies with the descriptive ...Wedo 0583001 bag with handle 4 rings Black (Office Supplies) Can not quite connect to the last album I think ...Runes (MP3 Download) Not quite like in the pictureREDBRIDGE by Cipo & Baxx Herren Chino RB-177 Color does not quite fit in the pictureZestyle hybrid Outdoor Hard Case Bumper Silicon Case Cover for iPhone 4 4S with Screen Protector (money)