Ordinary equipment but too slow for the interfaces

Ordinary equipment but too slow for the interfaces

Buffalo HD-PA1.0TU3 EU MiniStation Thunderbolt 6.4 cm (2.5-inch) External Hard Drive 1TB (16MB cache, 5400rpm, USB 3.0) (Personal Computers)

Customer Review

The external 2.5 "1TB Thunderbolt / USB3 HDD from Buffalo is equipped with a solid, smart housing, and makes a good impression.
A chic design is paired with good equipment, USB 3 and Thunderbolt cables lie. Here there is nothing wrong - quite the contrary: the facilities are great! The board does not require a separate power connection. His current concerns there about the respective connection, either via the USB or Thunderbolt cable. Especially for mobile use, it's great, no more cables on the road need to be.

The packaging and product description is confusing and does not reflect the achievable under real circumstances facts. It is advertised with obvious 5GB / s interface speed USB3 and 10GB / s in 2 directions interface speed at Thunderbolt. That's all well and good - but the most important information, the information that is relevant in practice: in a nutshell: the only thing that is really important is not disclosed: That you will never reach these values ​​by far with this product. That will indeed be touched far down in the small print - it but no, the above chart with the achsotollen USB & Thunderbolt looks at speeds respects.

When 1TB model a conventional hard disk is installed. No matter what speeds could be achieved depending on maximum with the interfaces USB3 and Thunderbolt: The disk is the bottleneck. And so are real values ​​of 80-105 MB per second read and write to USB3 and Thunderboltverbindungen - tested on a iMac in 2012 and 2011 on a Macbook possible. This corresponds to the usual hard drive values ​​and is much lower than permitted by the interfaces of USB3 or Thunderbolt.

The values ​​themselves are tidy and for many users, the (usually 20-30 real MB / s, depending on the device) or Firewire 800 (50-70 real MB / sec) Change from USB2, the plate acts satisfactory or even surprising quickly. But they are far from the values ​​that can be reached with the interfaces (theoretical: 640 MB / second at USB3 or 1,280 MB / second with Thunderbolt) away. This Buffalo 1TB disk provides a maximum of 105 MB / s: If you connect, for example, two with internal SSD equipped Macs together, are by Thunderbolt cable for over 200MB / s in read and write possible. All values ​​are read using the OS X Activity Monitor.

Because of the enormous discrepancy between the real Values ​​to be achieved to the maximum interface port rate and due to the exaggerated advertising on the product packaging with interface speeds, without mentioning the real achievable values ​​really gets this record from me 4 of 5 stars.

for lavish gentlemen ... Rank: 5/5
April 20
Original colors Rank: 5/5
March 17
When we love, we love 1 Rank: 4/5
March 8
Excellent value 538 Rank: 5/5
March 9

Related Reviews


Good, but too slow for the Samsung NX3000 system camera!Samsung Memory 32GB microSDHC Class 6 Memory Card Standard Memory Card (up to 24MB / s data transfer rate) with SD adapter (accessory) Convenient but too small for the TG1Olympus Tough Case multifunction neoprene + nylon belt clip carabiner + + + armband strap for TG-1, TG830, TG-820, TG-620 (Accessory) good bag but too narrow for the RX100 !!!Lowepro Apex 20 AW camera bag black (Camera) Schick but too small for the Optimus 3DMobile cross Case for LG Optimus 3D P920 / E900 Optimus 7 / BL40 with belt loop Black (Electronics) Delivery is fast true angel sweet but too expensive for the sizeEngelsfigur ON HANDS WITH HEART 10 CM NEW Beautiful bag, but too large for the QX30Sturdy, padded bag for Sony DSC-QX30 / ILCE QX1 compact camera lenses in style + cloth (Electronics) Innovative concept, but too limited for the momentGigaset Elements Safety Pack for White connected home (Electronics) Convenient but too expensive for the quality.Marto Wall holder f.histor. Swords (Sports Apparel) Beautiful coat, but too cold for the winter!Laeticia Dreams ladies winter jacket trench coat hood XS SML XL XXL New (Textiles) Good, but too expensive for the officeCanon PGI-5BK Original Black Ink Cartridge (Office Supplies) Quiet but too imprecise for the priceQUIET MECHANISM CLOCK WITH 3 SETS OF NEEDLE (Watch) Film good but too small for the Lumix DMC-TC613 x atFoliX protector Panasonic Lumix DMC-TZ61 Screen Protector - FX antireflective glare-free (electronic) Cool game, but too slow, when the galaxies are too largeSins of a Solar Empire: Rebellion (video game) good lighting films, but too expensive for the small amount!Wagalum luminescent films for the stroller (Baby Product) affordable camper equipment - but watch out for the deliverySAT Campingkoffer 38 cm steel antenna with tripod made of aluminum (Electronics) super, but too small for the window 130x150cmFlyscreen window 130x150cm white insect (household goods) Super quality, but too heavy for the size.KLICKfix bag DAYPACK BOX Lenkertasche, 0215S (equipment) Ok but too expensive for the quality!Original ICarer Leather Case for Apple iPhone 4 & 4S / Chrome Edition Case phone shell protective sleeve leather sleeve folding Case Flip Cover Hard Bumper Electroplaiting Black. (Electronics) Nice, but too expensive for the qualityDaniel Wellington Ladies Watch Bristol analog quartz leather 0511DW (clock)